Piedmont 150 plate scratch(es) progress

[iwantitiwinit]

No doubt that Cobb and Tinker were positioned on different sheets in the exact same spot. Nice post.

[t206hound]

I've followed this thread and kept track of various clues that could help put these sheets together. Pat has speculated (and I agree) that there were different press runs during the Piedmont 150 phase. To the best of my knowledge, none of the two-namer cards have plate scratches, but there are known two-namer subjects that have plate scratches.

Following is the list of Piedmont 150 two-namers that are known, but to the best of my knowledge, none of them have plate scratches. I think I have a few of these images/cards at home, but can anyone else provide backs of any of these cards?

Those that are red bold have images below (12/20 images; none have plate scratch):
Beaumont - Seymour
Bender (port.) - Delehanty (Wash.) [there are two of these]
Bergen (bat) - Dooin
Brown, M (port.) - Magee (port.)
Bradley (port.) - Bender (port.)
Devlin - Schulte (front view)
Hinchman, B. - Stovall (port.)
Jennings (port.) - Jordan (port.)
Johnson (port.) - Schlei (catching)
Konetchy - Jennings (port.)
Killian (pitching) - Chance (red port.)
Lindaman - Bresnahan (port.)
Lundgren (Cubs) - Doolin
Lundgren (Cubs) - Ball (New York)
Manning (batting) - Flick
Pastorius - Lake (NY, throw)
Powell (horizontal) - O'Leary (port.) [there are two of these]
Shipke - Griffith
Spade - Cicotte
Walsh - Seymour (batting)

[Luke]

Jennings/Jordan & WaJo/Schlei (not my card unfortuantely)

[t206hound]

I don't see scratches on these:

Bender-Delehanty (mine, one of two known)
Bergen-Dooin (not mine)
Killian-Chance (mine)

[t206hound]

From the two names thread:

M. Brown (Portrait) - Magee


Powell - O'Leary


Walsh - Seymour


Shipke - Griffith


Lundgren - Ball

[Pat R]

Erick, I haven't seen any two-name cards with plate scratches either.

It's interesting that's there's a Pastorius-Lake and a Lake-Pastorius.

Here's the Manning-Flick.

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by Pat R

Erick, I haven't seen any two-name cards with plate scratches either.

It's interesting that's there's a Pastorius-Lake and a Lake-Pastorius.

Here's the Manning-Flick.

Ack! That's a mistake. Went back to the original thread and I had copied in Chris' information and he listed it as Top/Bottom. When I updated later I didn't see the card listed as Bottom/Top, so I added it.

In short, they don't both exist. The correct subjects are Pastorius-Lake. Updating lists above.

Here's the Pastorius-Lake from the Favorite 2015 Pick-Ups thread:

[iwantitiwinit]

Originally Posted by t206hound

From the two names thread:

M. Brown (Portrait) - Magee


Powell - O'Leary


Walsh - Seymour


Shipke - Griffith


Lundgren - Ball

Imagine if that were a Magie rather than a Magee!! Does a 2 name Magie exist? If it does I want it.

[Pat R]

.