Was told to post these pins in here so I am.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Heres more

[batsballsbases]

Hello I dont like to comment to much on seaweed as he is high on his prices but I will tell you at least one of the pins is a repro . The Ted Williams that the name band goes all the way past his shoulder is a repro. Also I hope you didnt buy that purple Blitzkreg brooklyn pin as he has been told (I did see it sold) that it has nothing to do with the dodgers. Here is the 2 williams pins the one on the left is real. shorter name band.. Plus the little pennants that he puts on most of his pins never came with them.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by batsballsbases

Hello I dont like to comment to much on seaweed as he is high on his prices but I will tell you at least one of the pins is a repro . The Ted Williams that the name band goes all the way past his shoulder is a repro. Also I hope you didnt buy that purple Blitzkreg brooklyn pin as he has been told (I did see it sold) that it has nothing to do with the dodgers. Here is the 2 williams pins the one on the left is real. shorter name band.. Plus the little pennants that he puts on most of his pins never came with them.

Ugh that is very worrisome as he assured me they are all authentic and he has acquired them from stadiums. I'm not the type to back out but thinking about it as that doesn't make me fee too good.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by batsballsbases

Hello I dont like to comment to much on seaweed as he is high on his prices but I will tell you at least one of the pins is a repro . The Ted Williams that the name band goes all the way past his shoulder is a repro. Also I hope you didnt buy that purple Blitzkreg brooklyn pin as he has been told (I did see it sold) that it has nothing to do with the dodgers. Here is the 2 williams pins the one on the left is real. shorter name band.. Plus the little pennants that he puts on most of his pins never came with them.

Are the pennants real do you think?

[matty39]

The pennants are real but not very rare. A few are 1936-38 bf3s. Several are 1950 American Nut & Chocolates, and a few are very common 1950s mini-pennants. Nothing very special about any of them. Like Al said, they never came with the pins. IMO the value of the pennants range from 10 to 30 dollars individually.

[iwantitiwinit]

Didn't you just purchase that fake 54 Aaron for $1300 also? Seems like you may be going about things the wrong way. Just a suggestion but why not ask for opinions on authenticity and value before making substantial purchases.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by iwantitiwinit

Didn't you just purchase that fake 54 Aaron for $1300 also? Seems like you may be going about things the wrong way. Just a suggestion but why not ask for opinions on authenticity and value before making substantial purchases.

Yes just got a refund tonight for that card thank goodness.

[batsballsbases]

I can and will tell you that most of the pins that he has are real. Just not all of them. (3) in the postings I see are not. As Matty39 said the little mini pennants are real but 99.9 percent of these never came with the PM10 stadium pins. The only ones I have seen are some of the cubs pins with a small cubs pennant on them. Eric(seaweed) is a member here and I dont want to ruin his deal with you so I willnot tell you which ones are not period. I have collected pins for over 40 years and its very hard to give an education here in 5 minutes. But as was stated maybe you should do a little more research before putting up the money you are saying your spending.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by batsballsbases

I can and will tell you that most of the pins that he has are real. Just not all of them. (3) in the postings I see are not. As Matty39 said the little mini pennants are real but 99.9 percent of these never came with the PM10 stadium pins. The only ones I have seen are some of the cubs pins with a small cubs pennant on them. Eric(seaweed) is a member here and I dont want to ruin his deal with you so I willnot tell you which ones are not period. I have collected pins for over 40 years and its very hard to give an education here in 5 minutes. But as was stated maybe you should do a little more research before putting up the money you are saying your spending.

Thank you AL. Are any of the jackies fake? That's why I bought these. Thanks

[ooo-ribay]

I've always assumed seaweed's pins were legit but I've never understood the rationale for adorning them with mini pennants not original to the pins...

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by batsballsbases

I can and will tell you that most of the pins that he has are real. Just not all of them. (3) in the postings I see are not. As Matty39 said the little mini pennants are real but 99.9 percent of these never came with the PM10 stadium pins. The only ones I have seen are some of the cubs pins with a small cubs pennant on them. Eric(seaweed) is a member here and I dont want to ruin his deal with you so I willnot tell you which ones are not period. I have collected pins for over 40 years and its very hard to give an education here in 5 minutes. But as was stated maybe you should do a little more research before putting up the money you are saying your spending.

Agree that 99% of the little pennants never came with the pins. But another example I can think of (which I believe to be as issued) are the little orange Giants pennants that accompany Pins like Hubbell, Bartell, Melton, etc.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

Originally Posted by matty39

The pennants are real but not very rare. A few are 1936-38 bf3s. Several are 1950 American Nut & Chocolates, and a few are very common 1950s mini-pennants. Nothing very special about any of them. Like Al said, they never came with the pins. IMO the value of the pennants range from 10 to 30 dollars individually.

Thank you Matty! As far as the pins go, what do you think about the value on those? I bought them all to keep the robinsons and resell the rest. At 3000 was that too rich of authentic? Are they authentic?