Dispute with an auction company

[sbfinley]

Originally Posted by Stanesq

I never cracked open the binder until I received a call from the Auction Company owner asking me to return the 1997 Topps. Unfortunately I had sold 5 cards from the lot, all commons, the best one being Ruben Rivera. I sent the binder back and the owner tells me we are missing 14 cards, no one major who was pictured.

How is this possible?


Sounds like a mess all around. No offense.

[Abeabe]

How can you sell cards from a binder you never cracked open?

[Stanesq]

Originally Posted by sbfinley

How is this possible?


Sounds like a mess all around. No offense.

While I agree it needs to be sorted out, my paying for the sold cards (for which I received a whopping $25) at a rate of $3 per card would have been $42.

The fact that I had my thyroid removed (due to tumors) and thus my health issue is what made me not really concerned about that set or any other as I was fighting for my health.

I never would have guessed that had I looked I would be missing all those stars. In this hobby we buy autographs trusting that what you send will be real and that if I win a lot of 484 cards I get 484. I dont expect that they will send me 364 and not have the stars that I paid for.