Beckett vs SGC for value in post war....

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Leon

Hey Guys
A question or two ...... We know PSA has the registry and high end cards that go with it tied up, especially the post war and later cards. Those cards usually bring more money in a PSA holder because of the almighty number on the flip. However, right below the registry high end stuff do ya'll think post war cards sell for more in SGC or BVG/BGS? Personally, I am being agnostic in my approach to this issue when acquiring cards....I even have a BCCG or two .....I also like raw cards in this space. Coffee talk....

Lastly, will you acquire the highest end cards in holders besides PSA knowing they might be worth less?

I not sure what you mean 'worth less'. If its the same price for a PSA and a BVG, yeah that could happen. But i am assuming you are paying less for the BVG card of the same grade, so it would be worth the same as what you paid at that time. I sold a SGC 7 Aaron pretty easily here and i paid much less for it then i would have a PSA 7. 10 years ago people who paid the same for each company are finding out one is worth less than the other but i would think now you are paying what the card is worth..

[Leon]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

I not sure what you mean 'worth less'. If its the same price for a PSA and a BVG, yeah that could happen. But i am assuming you are paying less for the BVG card of the same grade, so it would be worth the same as what you paid at that time. I sold a SGC 7 Aaron pretty easily here and i paid much less for it then i would have a PSA 7. 10 years ago people who paid the same for each company are finding out one is worth less than the other but i would think now you are paying what the card is worth..

I hope I am paying what cards are worth. My difference is I am not buying "flips" and I might be the only not doing that? Most seem to care more about the plastic and opinion of a grader than the card. I guess I will be on an island by myself with my cards. But they will be nice looking cards...

[Peter_Spaeth]

My belief and it could be wrong is that for most reasonably expensive cards in a BVG holder, there is a story that started with PSA or SGC or both. I too have heard the rumors about grading sheet cut.