The official Mickey Mantle Pickup Thread. All Mick, all the time!

[clydepepper]

1952 Bowman MICKEY MANTLE PSA-5.jpg

1953 Bowman MICKEY MANTLE PSA-5.jpg

1953 Topps MICKEY MANTLE PSA-5.jpg

1954B MICKEY MANTLE PSA7.jpg

1956 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA7.jpg

1958 Topps- MANTLE & AARON PSA-7.jpg

1958 Topps- MICKEY MANTLE ALL STAR PSA-7.jpg

1959 Topps MICKEY MANTLE PSA-7.jpg

1959 Topps- MICKEY MANTLE ALL STAR PSA-7.jpg

1960 Topps MICKEY MANTLE PSA-7.jpg

1960 Topps- MICKEY MANTLE ALL STAR PSA-7.jpg

1961 Topps- MICKEY MANTLE ALL STAR PSA-7.jpg

1962 Topps MICKEY MANTLE PSA-7.jpg

1962 Topps- MANTLE & MAYS PSA-7.jpg

1962 Topps- MICKEY MANTLE ALL STAR PSA-7.jpg

1964 Topps Stand-Up- MICKEY MANTLE PSA-7.jpg

1968 Topps- KILLEBREW, MAYS & MANTLE PSA-8.jpg

[orly57]

A couple of upgrades:

[orly57]

And:

[irv]

Sweet!

[vintagebaseballcardguy]

In the mail today...

[ALR-bishop]

Orlando--if your other 67 does not have the red dot above the S in Yankees, it is not an upgrade, it is the second of 3 versions of this card

This was discussed in the long variations thread. Anyone think Topps tried to do something with the bat knob in Mantle's sweet spot ? Some say yes, others no. Since the ones that look a little different are the scarcer of the two, maybe just a print defect rather than intentional fudging

[tedzan]

TED Z
.

[tedzan]

.





TED Z
.

[tedzan]

TED Z
.

[tedzan]

TED Z
.

[irv]

Originally Posted by tedzan

.





TED Z
.

Great cards, Ted. Love that Mantle/Berra card especially.

[tedzan]

1952-55 Dormand p/c


.


TED Z
.

[AustinMike]

Originally Posted by tedzan

TED Z
.

Ted, when and what is this from?

[MK]

The Mick was my boyhood idol. Saw him hit a homer over the center field fence at Comiskey Park which is still my biggest thrill. The 1961 season has great memories for me and I have collected a few things shown here.

[tedzan]

Mantle's HOF placard ............and, a highly sought after Red Man card of Mantle......that never was





TED Z
.

[KCRfan1]

Ted,

I'm always fascinated with your collections and the knowledge you have of cards. How did you acquire the Red Man Mantle, and what prevented the card from being issued?

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by KCRfan1

Ted,

I'm always fascinated with your collections and the knowledge you have of cards. How did you acquire the Red Man Mantle, and what prevented the card from being issued?

Hi Lou

Thanks for the compliments.

I acquired this Red Man Mantle in a collection I purchased some years ago.

My guess is that the Bowman Gum Co. had exclusive rights to Mantle, and that is why he was not included
with the 1952 - 1955 Red Man issues.

And perhaps, to a certain degree the same applies to why Mantle was not in the 1954 and 1955 Topps sets.


TED Z
.

[tedzan]

Hey guys......when is the last time you saw this Mantle card ?





TED Z
.

[ALR-bishop]

Someone posted one of these on CU so I picked one up because I of have a few other Topps player tribute posters that picture all of the player's Topps and Bowman cards. I just posted the four I have in a separate thread to see if anyone knows of others. I have all the card portrayed but think they make neat room decor in my study.

The certificate from Topps says 10,000 of the Mantle poster were produced

[tedzan]

Hi Al

That's a great looking poster.


TED Z
.

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Hey guys......when is the last time you saw this Mantle card ?





TED Z
.

I'm surprised at the lack of curiosity on this forum regarding this Mantle card.

Anyhow......I did receive a couple of emails from Net54 "readers" inquiring about the source of this "1954 TOPPS" Mantle. On display here is a partial picture of
Sports Illustrated (Aug 23, 1954) edition with the centerfold-out depicting 27 players on the New York Yankees.

Back in the early 1980's a collector/dealer and ole friend, Charlie, who frequented the Willow Grove Show gave me this card. Charlie had a printer buddy of his,
using the image of Mantle from this centerfold-out, produced a number of these cards. I have not seen any of these in circulation since the mid-1980's.






TED Z
.

[KCRfan1]

Ted,

You always have cool stuff!!!

[pawpawdiv9]

Hey TED..
I actually was browsing last week on the 54 mantle--the red version, which is common
I did run across the 'white' version on Ebay too, which I had never seen before, just like your 'blue' version.
I did see a graded PSA red one..Why would someone grade one of these?

[brian1961]

Ted,

Thanks for enlightening us on the history of your "1954 Sports Illustrated Topps" enhanced blue version. I was wracking my brain trying to recall the reprints that Larry Fritsch offered, but as I remember now, duh, they were straight reprints.

I love yours with the blue background, but then I have always admired the George Silk portrait of Mickey taken during his rookie year and used by LIFE magazine in the spring 1951 when they ran a brief feature on Mickey's major league debut.

Much as I love the 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes "1954 Topps" version, the George Silk portrait is such a gem, being still appropriate in the time frame for a 1954 Topps. After all, that's the shot SI chose for its 1954 spread of the Yanks!

I for one would love to own a specimen of your printing buddy Charlie's craftsmanship.

Best regards, Brian Powell

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by brian1961

Ted,

Thanks for enlightening us on the history of your "1954 Sports Illustrated Topps" enhanced blue version. I was wracking my brain trying to recall the reprints that Larry Fritsch offered, but as I recall now, duh, they were straight reprints.

I love yours with the blue background, but then I have always admired the George Silk portrait of Mickey taken during his rookie year and used by LIFE magazine in the spring 1951 when they ran a brief feature on Mickey's major league debut.

Much as I love the 1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes "1954 Topps" version, the George Silk portrait is such a gem, being still appropriate in the time frame for a 1954 Topps. After all, that's the shot SI chose for its 1954 spread of the Yanks!

I for one would love to own a specimen of your printing buddy Charlie's craftsmanship.

Best regards, Brian Powell

Hi Brian

I haven't had any contact with Charlie since the Fort Washington (PA) Shows in 2001.

I cannot promise you anything, but I will try to contact collectors (dealers) in Pennsylvania that may still have (or know how I can get) this Mantle card.





TED Z
.

[tedzan]

Continuing in the trend of the last 10 posts here with Mantle reprints, here is one more......



.


This card was an insert in Bob Lemke's semi-annual "Baseball Cards" magazine (issue Oct 1984).



TED Z
.

[brian1961]

[QUOTE=tedzan;1559964]Hi Brian

I haven't had any contact with Charlie since the Fort Washington (PA) Shows in 2001.

I cannot promise you anything, but I will try to contact collectors (dealers) in Pennsylvania that may still have (or know how I can get) this Mantle card.


Thanks, Ted. I'm deeply touched. I fully understand you cannot promise anything. Besides, hard as it may seem for us sometimes, that was a long time ago. The card reminds me how powerful a little color can go towards making a remarkable one. Just as it did for the '49 Bowmans, and with more color, for the 1961-62 Fleer basketball.

Thank you again, bro.

Best regards, Brian Powell

[clydepepper]

Originally Posted by ALR-bishop

Someone posted one of these on CU so I picked one up because I of have a few other Topps player tribute posters that picture all of the player's Topps and Bowman cards. I just posted the four I have in a separate thread to see if anyone knows of others. I have all the card portrayed but think they make neat room decor in my study.

The certificate from Topps says 10,000 of the Mantle poster were produced

I wonder why they left the '52 & '53 Bowmans out. Looks like for 'artistic balance' ?

[orly57]

Scratch a big one off the list:

[Stonepony]

Originally Posted by orly57

Scratch a big one off the list:

Great card, Orlando. One of my favorite issues and image!!

[brian1961]

Originally Posted by orly57

Scratch a big one off the list:

Orlando, heartiest of congratulations on getting a Stahl-Meyer Franks Mickey Mantle. Nice card for the grade.

Perchance you might be interested in learning more about the Stahl-Meyer Franks promotion and this Mickey Mantle gem, I wrote about them in my recently released book, NEVER CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN. I cover a nice selection of the regionals from 1947 - 1971. It is not a standard book; it's a book on a CD. Works easily and very well---you read it by inserting the CD into the disc drive of your computer or laptop. It's the equivalent of a 478-page book, including about 32 mostly color photos, which will look gorgeous on your computer screen.

If interested, send me a $30 money order. The postal service charges only $1.20 for theirs. I'm at

Brian Powell
P. O. Box 743
New Carlisle, Indiana 46552

After getting the Stahl-Meyer Mick, I think I can more than reasonably assure you you shan't be disappointed with my book.

Regardless, again, nice going bro on the acquisition of a regal Mickey Mantle baseball card. ---Brian

[begsu1013]

.

[brian1961]

Bob, I'm afraid to disappoint you here, but the first compromise I made with my book was to deviate from the standard traditional paper book. My editor, Tom Bartsch, and I were gunning for that. I won't explain all our trials and tribulations, but it came down to a Hobson's Choice with my book on a CD.

I'm mostly dinosaur, so a book on a CD was a hefty compromise. You're right, of course, a book on a CD is basically a thing of the past. ANYTHING printed on paper is slowly going away. I cannot relate to or understand, digital downloads. However, most of us have disc drives on our computers or laptops. It is do-able if the collector is motivated enough to accept it for what it is, and work within its parameters. Believe me when I say that its appearance on the computer screen mirrors an open book, with an easy on the eye font, and looks fabulous. The book was not whipped out---it took me years to write and edit it, after many, many more years of gathering research and interviewing some very renown and pertinent hobby pioneers and major figures from the past. The information and interpretive investigative collecting 501 is ultra prime rib material.

With it being the equivalent of a 478-page book, the buyer is not getting short-changed, believe me. Oh, the $30 money order I ask is the bottom line price; the book, housed in a sturdy half-inch thick DVD case, is mailed to you postpaid--first class.

I hope this convinces you, Bob. Thank you for your interest, bro.

Regards, Brian Powell

[ALR-bishop]

I guard my 1848 page 2011 SCD Standard Catalog, the last one with post 1980 listings. I do not like CDS or digital downloads. I am really old

[begsu1013]

.

[judgebuck]

Orlando,

Congratulations on the 1953 Stahl Meyer Mantle. I got mine (PSA 2 (MK) a year or so ago. That card and the 1960 Post Cereal Mantle are my two favorite Mantle cards. 1959 Bazooka is a close third.

I haven't pulled the trigger on buying Brian's book (CD) yet, but I should. I'm sure it would be filled with information and pictures on the above three issues as well as many more, such as 1954 Dan Dee, 1954 Red Heart, etc.

judgebuck (David)

[Bestdj777]

Brian, you can pull the PDF, so you should be able to either send it as an attachment to an email (depending on size) or put it on an FTP site (drop box?) where someone can retrieve a copy. It beats driving to the post office.

I love my copy--I printed mine off and now have it in hard copy--and it's a fantastic book.

Oh, and gorgeous Stahl Meyer!

[KCRfan1]

What a find Orly! Congrats on the card!!!!

[brian1961]

Originally Posted by judgebuck

Orlando,

Congratulations on the 1953 Stahl Meyer Mantle. I got mine (PSA 2 (MK) a year or so ago. That card and the 1960 Post Cereal Mantle are my two favorite Mantle cards. 1959 Bazooka is a close third.

I haven't pulled the trigger on buying Brian's book (CD) yet, but I should. I'm sure it would be filled with information and pictures on the above three issues as well as many more, such as 1954 Dan Dee, 1954 Red Heart, etc.

judgebuck (David)

David, All the issues you mention are covered in a chapter, except the Red Heart. I had to draw the line somewhere; however, I devoted several pages to the beautiful Red Hearts in my conclusion chapter, and reveal why I chose not to give it the full chapter treatment. Nothing really negative, believe me.

Anyways, David, the ball is now in your court---you shan't be sorry, bro.

All the best, your pal, Brian Powell

[brian1961]

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

Brian, you can pull the PDF, so you should be able to either send it as an attachment to an email (depending on size) or put it on an FTP site (drop box?) where someone can retrieve a copy. It beats driving to the post office.

I love my copy--I printed mine off and now have it in hard copy--and it's a fantastic book.

Oh, and gorgeous Stahl Meyer!

Chris, glad to finally hear from you, even if indirectly. You made my day---I really needed to hear at least a few of your feelings on NEVER CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN.

My post office is less than a mile away, but I appreciate the advice. Perhaps one day, but I would like to sell the remaining copies of the 1,000 I had printed in the first place.

Give me a buzz some time Chris. Let's talk! ---Brian

[brian1961]

Originally Posted by ALR-bishop

I guard my 1848 page 2011 SCD Standard Catalog, the last one with post 1980 listings. I do not like CDS or digital downloads. I am really old

Ah, come on, Al! A few years back, I would have turned my nose up on such a notion as a book on a CD. This old dinosaur adapted to a CD book very smoothly. It's easy. It works---beautifully!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I get the feeling collectors want things their way, or no way, as at a fast food joint. If they could hear their words and the tone of how they're coming across. Whilst I truly understand and can commisserate to a point, a collector must understand we are living in a changing world where our hobby is considered a thing of the past, not to mention chock full of opportunistic crooks. Publishers "ain't" interested in feeding us printed books about our subject.

So, when a book truly devoted to our a hobby and a great period of time in card production and collecting finally comes along, but it's on a CD, and said collectors bellyache as Curly did in ALL THE WORLD'S A STOOGE, "I don't like spinach!", it's all I can do not to spit back with, "It's time you start living with your thumb out of yo' mouth!"

Ooh, I guess I said it anyway.

Well, Al, you think about it. I know thirty smackers is not the issue with you. As I've told many others, I shan't think for a moment you will be disappointed.

Perhaps you can ask your friend Jacqueline Bisset her advice on the matter.

--- Brian Powell

[ALR-bishop]

Brian---do you discus this one on the CD ? ;-)


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Mickey-Mantl...cAAOSwanRXgbaO

[mcreel]

Originally Posted by ALR-bishop

Brian---do you discus this one on the CD ? ;-)


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Mickey-Mantl...cAAOSwanRXgbaO

Picked this up at a show yesterday.



Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk

[Canofcorn]

Able to snag this last night from PWCC while everyone else was going for the high end.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Canofcorn

Able to snag this last night from PWCC while everyone else was going for the high end.

I lucked out (or at least I think I did?) on 3 low end 52 Topps cards likely for the same reason?

Figured, being since all 3 were slabbed,(and I needed them) that I likely spent less on them than what it cost the person to get them graded?

[mrmantlecollector]

Originally Posted by LuckyLarry

I'm always on the lookout for extra Mantle cards. And I don't care what they look like if the price is right. Recent pick-ups:
1953 Bowman color #44 the Standard Catalog says the NM "value" is $775 I paid $15 or 1.9% book.
1957 Topps #407 the Standard Catalog says the NM "value" $465 this card cost me $14 or 3% book.
Larry

Great cards got to like a bargain. Here's a couple bargains I picked up.

[orly57]

Finally snagged the Topps Super. This one is a psa 5. Most of the Supers come in ultra high grades, but I was happy to find a more affordable mid-grade to scratch off the list.

[CxG Seven Dust]

Originally Posted by Canofcorn

Able to snag this last night from PWCC while everyone else was going for the high end.

Nicely centered too!

[brian1961]

Originally Posted by orly57

Finally snagged the Topps Super. This one is a psa 5. Most of the Supers come in ultra high grades, but I was happy to find a more affordable mid-grade to scratch off the list.

Orlando---

I dearly love this card of Mick, ever since the first time I saw it. Whilst going through the set, I glimpsed the Mantle, and bought the set on the spot. It was July of 1972, at the Midwest Sports Collectors Convention in Troy, Michigan. I bought it from Bill Haber, a kind man who worked at Topps, and drew their cartoon artwork on the backsides. He'd brought a black satchel along with him, full of papers, letters, what have you, and about a dozen brand new gleaming mint sets of the '69 Topps Supers, I suppose to help fund his journey to Michigan from New York, as well as a few card purchases. That set was worth every penny.

Extra nice pick-up, Orlando. Nothing jumps out to me in a bad way about your fine card. The colors and picture registry are flawless. By the by, isn't it nice that you rarely have to be concerned with centering defects on these '69 Topps Supers!

Anyway, congratulations, bro. ---Brian Powell

[MikeGarcia]

....When I picked this up many years ago I didn't know much about sixties cards , still don't actually , but the first time I saw this I actually at first thought it was a Bob Lemke fantasy card , one of those beautiful center-page-binding stiff stock inserts , and his connections to Sports Collectors Digest magazine and the grading company that they had had 'way back then at that time just re-inforced my thought process . Managers' Dream indeed. They could just as well have named it "pitchers' nightmare".


... Hi Bob , hope all is well...

..