FS: 1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson PSA 5 -

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

I was going to stay out of this one but I would like to make a proposal. Boyton, Calvin's posts were inappropriate in the context of just thread, but were made because you tend to do the same thing in many other BST threads, including one of his recently.

Can we all agree to stop posting unwanted suggestions and comments, other than nice card, in BST threads in the future? If you agree to do this Boyton I'm pretty sure everyone else will agree to stop commenting on yours.

And to Dean, when you typed PM sent, if your PM didn't say I will take it the card is still fair game. A seller shouldn't have to hold it and a buyer shouldn't have to wait simply because you asked a question or made an offer.

I said nothing close to what Calvin said. If Calvin can say what he did here because i stated that he may want to list a price, imagine what I should be able to put now on his. He did agree that VCP should be posted on all of our listings.

As to Dean, i was also the first to contact the seller (i was there first ) as well so even the issue that Peter disagrees with you on isnt an issue in my situation.

I am going to post in the manner you suggested on all future b/s/t listings.

However from this point on any more posts by Calvin that are outside the lines of b/s/t can we agree would now be totally out of line? (rhetorical) Anyway pkrplayer we will now test your theory, I will make another FS thread. There would be zero reason now for anyone to make commentary outside of b/s/t

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

I said nothing close to what Calvin said. If Calvin can say what he did here because i stated that he may want to list a price, imagine what I should be able to put now on his. He did agree that VCP should be posted on all of our listings.

As to Dean, i was also the first to contact the seller (i was there first ) as well so even the issue that Peter disagrees with you on isnt an issue in my situation.

I am going to post in the manner you suggested on all future b/s/t listings.

However from this point on any more posts by Calvin that are outside the lines of b/s/t can we agree would now be totally out of line? (rhetorical) Anyway pkrplayer we will now test your theory, I will make another FS thread. There would be zero reason now for anyone to make commentary outside of b/s/t

If you are agreeing not to post comments on BST threads at all, other than nice card, in the future then yes it would be inappropriate for others to do the same on your threads. Hopefully we can all stick to this and save the discussions and commentary for the appropriate sections of the forum.