Not again! This is why I have a problem with PWCC!! Sorry for the rant!

[Bored5000]

A "7" of that card actually sold for for $2,398 at Clean Sweep in 2013. The only other listing of a "7" on VCP sold for $1,171 at Memory Lane earlier this year. That does seem to be a huge disparity in prices for that grade, but the PWCC price is actually less than the card has sold for in the past at that grade.

The only auction for a "6" since 2012 that VCP is showing is a sale for $1,020 at Heritage earlier this year. Yes, your card did go for a few hundred dollars less than the previous sale of a "6" earlier this year.

[iwantitiwinit]

You are complaining that PWCC gets higher prices than you get for comparable cards at different grades and also that you get lower grades when you submit/consign to PWCC than they get for other similarly graded cards. You're going to have to limit your complaint to one of the two situations before I can give you some sympathy, can't have things both ways maybe you're dually unluckly.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by iwantitiwinit

You are complaining that PWCC gets higher prices than you get for comparable cards at different grades and also that you get lower grades when you submit/consign to PWCC than they get for other similarly graded cards. You're going to have to limit your complaint to one of the two situations before I can give you some sympathy, can't have things both ways maybe you're dually unluckly.

Maybe I'm not dually unlucky? Maybe the luck is coexistent with each other and it was just one luck?

[RedsFan1941]

is that the lefty grove you posted here was lost in the mail?

[Snapolit1]

One grade difference on the right card can bring a big price differential at times. However ridiculous. Not telling you anything you don’t already know.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Snapolit1

One grade difference on the right card can bring a big price differential at times. However ridiculous. Not telling you anything you don’t already know.

right key is POP....a babe ruth psa 4 to psa 5 in a 1933 goudey brings much bigger price difference than a 2 to 3 or 3 to 4 etc....same with t206 cobb

heck even if its the same grade..centering can be a 50% difference on cards in the 1000 dollar rage and more etc

plus you complained when you consigned cards to pwcc you dont do well...but when you sell on your own you give the cards away you say......

[sycks22]

The irony behind "I hate drama", but start a thread complaining about something. Isn't that kind of the definition of drama?

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

right key is POP....a babe ruth psa 4 to psa 5 in a 1933 goudey brings much bigger price difference than a 2 to 3 or 3 to 4 etc....same with t206 cobb

heck even if its the same grade..centering can be a 50% difference on cards in the 1000 dollar rage and more etc

plus you complained when you consigned cards to pwcc you dont do well...but when you sell on your own you give the cards away you say......

When I sell myself, I give cards away...more than if they sold with PWCC. When my cards do poorly with PWCC, it is when they have multiples of the same card, same grade up for auction. Maybe there is an ulterior motive why they dont do well, but that has been discussed ad naseum. No need to rehash THAT aspect of it again.

[edjs]

I remember that thread, I never saw that you posted resolution for that. Maybe people thought it was your stolen card? I wouldn't bid on a card I thought was stolen, but if I thought it was stolen, I would have notified you when I saw it. Did anyone alert you of it listed on e-bay?

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by edjs

I remember that thread, I never saw that you posted resolution for that. Maybe people thought it was your stolen card? I wouldn't bid on a card I thought was stolen, but if I thought it was stolen, I would have notified you when I saw it. Did anyone alert you of it listed on e-bay?

Yes..same card.....I don't know if he wants me to out him here, but a fellow board member helped me recover it. It was in post office "limbo" an extra week, and no one knew where it was. It all of the sudden showed up. And I proceeded to lose $400 on it. That card was jinxed from the start.

[bobbyw8469]

PS - No one alerted me off Ebay. I'm just lamenting the fact that the only sellers who get bids are PWCC and Probstein. Let's face reality. Any other seller who lists cards for .99 cents just DOES NOT get the bids that those two gets. They run the risk of selling their items for peanuts. That's the facts.