T206 Magie/Magee Portrait Complete Back Run

[iwantitiwinit]

Holy smokes Pat nice!!!!!

[Rhotchkiss]

Real nice! And the PSA pop report doesn't even show old mill as an option, let alone list any graded examples. I think the conclusion is that the Magee OM is quite rare, but hardly one-of-a-kind (graded) as (once) touted by Goodwin.

[iwantitiwinit]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Real nice! And the PSA pop report doesn't even show old mill as an option, let alone list any graded examples. I think the conclusion is that the Magee OM is quite rare, but hardly one-of-a-kind (graded) as (once) touted by Goodwin.

Yup I agree, in my 6 years of watching virtually every major and lesser auction and every t206 on sale on ebay the 2 goodwin cards are the only 2 I have seen for sale. I have been looking for an Elberfeld NY om and have been unable to find one.

[Luke]

Elberfeld NY OM doesn't exist. So you can cross that one off the list.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by Luke

Elberfeld NY OM doesn't exist. So you can cross that one off the list.

I wish that someone would tell me that Red Crosses don't exist. All my back runs would suddenly be complete.

[iwantitiwinit]

Originally Posted by Luke

Elberfeld NY OM doesn't exist. So you can cross that one off the list.

T206 says possible not confirmed on that Elberfeld NY OM same status that they showed the Magee portrait OM until a just 2 years ago.

[Luke]

Yeah, and I see why they do it that way, because we can't ever know with 100% certainty that it was never printed. However, in practice we can assume that one almost certainly doesn't exist. Just like a Sov350 Elberfeld Portrait Washington almost certainly doesn't exist and a SC 350/25 Elberfeld NY almost certainly doesn't exist. The only two backs that share Elberfeld NY & Elberfeld Port Wash are Piedmont 350 and SC 350/30. It kind of makes sense too as those two backs were printed in larger quantities than SC 350/25, Sov350 and Old Mill.

Magee is a different case because there are a handful floating out there. There have certainly been some collectors who have known that card exists (at least the guys who owned them). And card target has sales of the two PSA copies that Pat showed. With Elberfeld NY Old Mill, no one has seen it and most Old Mill collectors don't expect it to exist because it doesn't fit the pattern.

[MercuryAdrian]

19282ADB-FA63-4A1E-8863-F5AF7FE13C0D.jpg

I’ll just leave this here...
This one is mine... sorry NFS