Altering vs cleaning

[frankbmd]

Car Wash vs Body Shop

[drcy]

Originally Posted by frankbmd

Car Wash vs Body Shop

Agree. That sums it up well.

[ullmandds]

While we've discussed this topic numerous times on here...and we all have our own opinions on the topic. The reality is that any "alteration" that cannot be detected is just fine.

[jcc6252]

Here is a recently soaked example using warm water and blotting with a paper towel. The "Before" is a little exaggerated, thanks to HA's darkened scans. You would think such a prestigious AH could present more accurate scans. Anyway, I don't see a problem with this cleaning.

[irv]

Originally Posted by jcc6252

Here is a recently soaked example using warm water and blotting with a paper towel. The "Before" is a little exaggerated, thanks to HA's darkened scans. You would think such a prestigious AH could present more accurate scans. Anyway, I don't see a problem with this cleaning.

I have never cleaned a card before, but I am surprised to see that staining came out that easy with just warm water and a paper towel?

I assumed staining, compared to just dirt, embedded itself deeper into the card stock where a simple soak/paper towel wouldn't remove it?

[jcc6252]

Originally Posted by irv

I have never cleaned a card before, but I am surprised to see that staining came out that easy with just warm water and a paper towel?

I assumed staining, compared to just dirt, embedded itself deeper into the card stock where a simple soak/paper towel wouldn't remove it?

I think it depends on the substance. Dirt, grime, or even gum residue is more likely to come out .vs. tobacco juice or toning.

I believe most water soakings will not change the technical grade, just make the card more presentable.