Ed Kranepool sues Beckett Auctions

[ejharrington]

There's not a lot of gray area here; one of the two parties is flat out lying.

[insidethewrapper]

So did Kranepool give the jersey to Goodwin ? If he did, what happened to it ?

[Steve D]

Another possibility.....was it actually someone pretending to be Bill Goodwin?

Steve

[drcy]

There wasn't a contract on such a jersey? I would assume that Beckett has a contract or form for every consignment no matter how expensive or from whom, just as you have you have to fill out a form/contract for a card to be graded.

[D. Bergin]

$20,000 for a list of player contacts. Is that something an auction company would actually shell out that amount of money for?

[D. Bergin]

Originally Posted by Steve D

Another possibility.....was it actually someone pretending to be Bill Goodwin?

Steve

I'm wondering if that might be the most likely scenario.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by ejharrington

There's not a lot of gray area here; one of the two parties is flat out lying.

+1 Sadly I doubt Mr Kranepool has a leg to stand on without any proof of the transaction.

[Jim65]

Its kind of hard to believe they would rip off a well known player on such an easy to track item. On the other hand maybe the fact that there was no contract was too tempting. Sad story either way.

[Leon]

Hey Guys
Since this thread is running in parallel with the one on the front page

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=257287

I am going to lock this one. That way it can be more consolidated conversation. If anyone has an issue with it PM me...thanks