SGC to PSA - Crossover or crack it out and re-submit?

[Madi$on18joshua]

It’s that damn set registry! I’m trying to complete the 1915 CJ and I’ve got several in an SGC holder. I also have a t206 Magie error.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[iwantitiwinit]

Shouldn't that have been a consideration when you originally bought the card? Why buy the card if you weren't happy with it in an SGC holder or weren't willing at that time to resubmit?

[swarmee]

Actual advice: for high valued or high condition cards, try a crossover submission first with min grade selected. I would usually take 1 grade less, but if it's really valuable already inthe SGC holder, maybe just a 0.5 drop?
If they don't cross and you're sure they meet the requirements for the grade, then crack out for the 2nd submission.

[Frank A]

I never ever send a card from one grader to another in a holder. Crack it out. 90% of the time they come back the same grade.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Frank A

I never ever send a card from one grader to another in a holder. Crack it out. 90% of the time they come back the same grade.

Tell that to my Pete Rose rookie that went from an SGC '3' to PSA Authentic. Crackouts are a gamble.

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by iwantitiwinit

Shouldn't that have been a consideration when you originally bought the card? Why buy the card if you weren't happy with it in an SGC holder or weren't willing at that time to resubmit?

I started out that way but the cards do not come available very often, so I get what is available.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Madi$on18joshua

I started out that way but the cards do not come available very often, so I get what is available.

wish I had some cj's in psa holders i was looking to dump at a fraction of their value on you?