1952 mantle probstein

[frankrizzo29]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

Theory is that the same card is being sold in an SGC holder on the BST.

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=268826

http://goldinauctions.com/lot-44829.aspx

Ok, makes sense. I can assure everyone though that I still own the card in the PSA 9OC holder with no plans of selling it. I was shocked to see pics of my card showing up in the middle of a net54 spat.

[calvindog]

Originally Posted by frankrizzo29

Ok, makes sense. I can assure everyone though that I still own the card in the PSA 9OC holder with no plans of selling it. I was shocked to see pics of my card showing up in the middle of a net54 spat.

I'm lost. If you still own the PSA 9OC card how can it be for sale in an SGC 86 holder? Unless it's a different card.

[T206Collector]

Originally Posted by calvindog

I'm lost. If you still own the PSA 9OC card how can it be for sale in an SGC 86 holder? Unless it's a different card.

It's gotta be a different card. The window to get a card bought in last Fall's Goldin auction into a pre-10-point-scale SGC holder may not even exist -- not sure when SGC made the change over.

[frankrizzo29]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

It's gotta be a different card. The window to get a card bought in last Fall's Goldin auction into a pre-10-point-scale SGC holder may not even exist -- not sure when SGC made the change over.

I'm not sure if I posted the pic correctly, but attached is a "proof of existence " pic. 100% my card is different from the SGC card listed for sale in BST. Again, I bought this in Oct in the goldin auctions, I still own the card, and it is not for sale.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Just two cards with similar centering. Not exactly an earthshaking event.

And back to the subject of the thread, no explanation added yet by Rick as to the spot.

[calvindog]

Originally Posted by peter_spaeth

just two cards with similar centering. Not exactly an earthshaking event.

And back to the subject of the thread, no explanation added yet by rick as to the spot.

Backs are centered the same too.

2335B2A0-5951-4331-BFF5-BFD7E5EB0D95.jpg

[irv]

Originally Posted by calvindog

Backs are centered the same too.

Attachment 352869

Certainly looks like the exact same card but it looks like we are being fooled as both have to be, based on their respective slabs, different from one another.

Here's a straightened image.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by frankrizzo29

I'm not sure if I posted the pic correctly, but attached is a "proof of existence " pic. 100% my card is different from the SGC card listed for sale in BST. Again, I bought this in Oct in the goldin auctions, I still own the card, and it is not for sale.

What? No proof of existence sticker?