Diamond Dust punchboards - to punch or not to punch?

[Zan]

Thanks for reviving this. I am chasing the 1940 Hank Greenberg Diamond Dust punchboard card. In the Standard Catalog Lemke describes the cards being pushed out of the back of the board when a player pays the fee to play the game. What is interesting is that he detailed a checklist of dollar winner players and “consolation winners". He designated dollar winners in the checklist with an asterisk, all of which happen to match the player subjects of this board exactly.

I'm going to be punching the board later, because this is the closest I will be getting to the card, however it is the same one that Exhibitman punched above and did not get cards, so I am cautious.