Show professionally graded cards that you consider inadequately graded or in error.

[steve B]

I think this one got a generous grade, I wouldn't have gone much above a 2. Not that I'm unhappy with the grade it was given....


This one has a light crease starting at the top center and going almost to the center of the card. Probably from being removed from a plastic page.




I also have a few like this, when I see 50's and even the occasional 60 with rounded corners I get a fleeting moment of annoyance.

[tedzan]

Acquired this card several years ago. I thought it did not deserve an "A".
But, it didn't cost me much (so I cannot complain).






Anyhow, I recently, cracked it out....and, submitted it to SGC

.




This time they graded it a "60".....





TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[NiceDocter]

Great photo image but to me the side and bottom borders look to be a bit small....maybe slight trimming? What do you think?

[gabrinus]

Two I used to have...the Wagner batting is a Mother's Bread and the throwing is a Mino...Jerry

[mouschi]

A little tuesday morning T206 humor for you tobacco card aficionados out there

[steve B]

Originally Posted by NiceDocter

Great photo image but to me the side and bottom borders look to be a bit small....maybe slight trimming? What do you think?

That's pretty much the normal American Beauty. Except for how nicely it's centered. Most are skinny and sometimes a bit short, but way off center percentage wise.

[Leon]

How about ones they won't grade?

[bnorth]

Pretty sure this one should have received a Authentic grade.

[irv]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Here are 6 PSA got WAY wrong. The first picture has a PSA 9 and a PSA 7. The 9 is mislabeled, it has the cheapest of the error versions actually in the slab but it is labeled as the most expensive. The 7 is counterfeit just like the 2 PSA 8s pictured and the 2 PSA 9s. Yes it is fairly easy to get a counterfeit card into a PSA slab. I won't out the gentleman because I think he is a member here. He has an amazing collection of 89 Fleer Bill Ripken error versions all in PSA slabs. He has so many cards with alterations so obvious Stevie Wonder could see them but PSA slabbed them with a # for him.

For those that don't understand printing. Those counterfeit Ripken cards are 10X as hard to counterfeit than a 50s card with white borders.

This one just arrived yesterday, Ben.

Can you tell from the scans if it is real or not? (I should have done more homework prior to purchasing! )