Off-centered cards you love anyway...

[ALR-bishop]

There are 3 recurring versions of the 67 Mantle, the one posted above, one with a red dot above the S in Yankees and one with red dot above the black top border on right side

[Bigdaddy]

Originally Posted by ALR-bishop

There are 3 recurring versions of the 67 Mantle, the one posted above, one with a red dot above the S in Yankees and one with red dot above the black top border on right side

Mick looks a little off-center on that card.

My favorites

[jchcollins]

Originally Posted by rgpete

My favorites

I feel you on the '70 Ryan. Before I even knew what qualifers were, I got a copy of that card off eBay in a PSA 8 (OC), not understanding at the time why it was so much cheaper than other 8's. (This was 18 years ago). Then when I got it, I did some research and understood it was o/c beyond the tolerance top to bottom. I had not noticed at all from the scan, and the card had minty fresh corners...

[jchcollins]

That color though...

[bnorth]

Seems like most of the Al Kaline Band-Aid variation cards are OC.

[jchcollins]

Bumping this thread that I started more than 2 years ago.

Recent thought has again led me around to the conclusion that centering hyper-focus / paranoia is mostly still just the result of cognitive bias that was introduced to us 20-25 years ago along with the advent of professional grading. Does anyone honestly disagree? How many of you who were big into vintage cards in say - 1988 - can honestly say that centering was on your top 10 list? I'm sure there are a few, and that's fine. Sure, empirically I guess a perfectly centered card is preferable to 80/20 s-s if you are looking at them next to one another. But when did the lesser centered card just become inherently ugly and shunned?

I'm interested in researching this particular issue almost as a sub-hobby in terms of condition evolution. It's something that for some dumb reason endlessly fascinates me.

Anyone else?