Careful Friends, I don't like this Nodgrass

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by BigBeerGut

What a merry-go-round!

You guys eat PSA stuff daily then also act like their awful.

So weird.

I don't think you can throw us all in one category and say "you guys". There are a lot of differing opinions on PSA. Some still defend them because their cards hold the most value in the market and others don't like them because they can't (or as some believe) purposely don't identify altered cards consistently. But throwing us all in the same boat is just wrong.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by CobbSpikedMe

I don't think you can throw us all in one category and say "you guys". There are a lot of differing opinions on PSA. Some still defend them because their cards hold the most value in the market and others don't like them because they can't (or as some believe) purposely don't identify altered cards consistently. But throwing us all in the same boat is just wrong.

And it's also entirely possible that both are true.

That PSA is either incompetent or corrupt
And that they add and/or retain value

Just because a company has people that aren't all that good at what they're doing doesn't mean their product isn't wildly successful. (See - Most of the software industry, and pretty much all the companies that sell millions of cheap junky products through WalMart, Target, and Amazon. )