T206 Red Cobb or T206 Red Cobb?

[bnorth]

PSA card all day. The main 2 reasons are I like the background to be dark red, not orangeish. I also like Ty to be looking to the left, not to the right when facing me.

PSA 1.5 without a doubt. Better color, better image, sharper corners. And with the money you get from selling the SGC 4 you can buy more stuff!

[Stampsfan]

The 1.5 looks short on both top and bottom in the holder, while the 4 looks like it fits slightly better.

Hard to tell tho when they are not to scale with each other.

Which one measures out larger?

[BeanTown]

If both cards raw, the 350 back one gets my vote as the registry is better. Now, you have to figure out why each card got accessed the grade they did. Especially the PSA card, as I have no trust in them whatsoever when it comes to high dollar cards. If you are sold in bith cards, then go to the more rarer backside to own.

[RCMcKenzie]

Both are nice examples. I voted for the Polar Bear. You could always start a Red Cobb back-run...Rob

[JeremyW]

I like the clarity of the Sweet Caporal.

[Rhotchkiss]

PSA 1.5 looks short. Just sayin.

That said, I will go with the rarer back every day of the week

[Leon]

Thanks for the responses so far. I don't think either is trimmed and most likely the PB is larger than the Sweet Cap. I don't have the PB in hand yet as I just acquired it (from a reputable seller).
I do like big borders..

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by bnorth

PSA card all day. The main 2 reasons are I like the background to be dark red, not orangeish. I also like Ty to be looking to the left, not to the right when facing me.

Yes, this also...

[SikSyko]

I would say the Polar Bear back, but that is because I love those backs.