T206 Red Cobb or T206 Red Cobb?

Originally Posted by orly57

Here is a side by side. I have to say, I like the PSA better (on left). The color, registration, and corners are just better. Leon, you could probably make this pic bigger.

Agreed. Polar Bear back isn't that special. Sorry, its just not. The aesthetics are so much better on the PSA in pretty much every possible way. No one could possibly deny that without the graded slabs

[whelenfan]

the side by side pics really bring out the qualities of the PSA card! it does seem to look much better.

[Rhotchkiss]

Orlando!!! Great to hear from you. How are you?

The side by side pic is helpful. The PSA looks nicer, but it also looks much shorter. Confirming my vote for the bigger borders and rarer back

[MVSNYC]

PB for sure. The SC is short (not saying trimmed, but annoyingly short), and a diamond cut (which always irritates me).

[Leon]

Apparently members can't see. They should be graders. The 1.5 is actually larger than most. It isn't short.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Leon

Apparently members can't see. They should be graders. The 1.5 is actually larger than most. It isn't short.

That PB must be huge. I couldn't get them to line up perfect and the PB scan is about .5 percent smaller and still has noticeably larger borders.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by bnorth

That PB must be huge. I couldn't get them to line up perfect and the PB scan is about .5 percent smaller and still has noticeably larger borders.

It is huge. That is why I bought it. Kind of like all of the ones I posted. I might just keep both for now