Uncatalogued Old Judge list?

[RCMcKenzie]

I was looking for a topic on n172 photo wear rates the other day and stumbled upon Joe's Vermont Find thread. It's remarkable how much he knows about n172 cards.

A member posted about 6 weeks ago about a new Maroons player. The player was on the original checklist card, but had not been cataloged. I think Dean's Cards has it for sale...Rob

[oldjudge]

There are three cards of Tug Wilson, but he is misidentified on the cards as Joe Miller. Joe G. and I did an article about this several years ago. Check Old Cardboard.
As David said, I have annotated my book to refllect all changes since the book was published in 2008. However, there is no place where these changes are detailed. If we ever do an update they will be included there.

[Fred]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

There are three cards of Tug Wilson, but he is misidentified on the cards as Joe Miller. Joe G. and I did an article about this several years ago. Check Old Cardboard.
As David said, I have annotated my book to refllect all changes since the book was published in 2008. However, there is no place where these changes are detailed. If we ever do an update they will be included there.

I'd love to see that annotated book...

[oldjudge]

Fred-I wish there was an easy way to show it to you. There are quite a few interesting additions. My favorite, something I noticed one evening a few years ago, is that pose 7-2 of Varney Anderson is really someone else. This required the pose to be move to the correct player. Can you figure out who that player is?

[prewinter]

Thanks for the quick updates! I've been researching the Western Association season of 1888, and I have compiled rosters of the clubs from the preseason onward. Tug Wilson and Roscoe Coughlin were two players unaccounted for from their club's respective opening day roster.

[oldjudge]

Here is the Coughlin entry I added to my book:

[Leon]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Here is the Coughlin entry I added to my book:

I am sure it's always a pleasure to update the book except it could be another needed.😐

[insidethewrapper]

Would be nice to add all the updates to the 2008 book in a few page publication that collectors could obtain for around $ 5.00 and receive in letter form . This site is to share information and I'm glad to see the above posts are doing that , instead of all the secrecy at times in this hobby.