SGC and greed

[kevinlenane]

Even if something gets pressed and trimmed the actual sizes and measurements from edges and borders wont be the same - to a machine it is readily identifiable.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by kevinlenane

Even if something gets pressed and trimmed the actual sizes and measurements from edges and borders wont be the same - to a machine it is readily identifiable.

So for example...take one of the E93's from original collection I have...trim it up to sharpen corners so that it's size is comparable to other e93's originally cut a little smaller...the machine will not know this?

[kmac32]

Just looked through my S74 silks and 2 were encapsulated without the plastic sleeve the SGC person was talking about. In my opinion, these 2 cards look fine and maybe even better than the others. Unless they can prove to me that this helps preserve the card better, there is absolutely no need to do this other than to take money from my bank account. Have emailed them about encapsulating without the additional plastic and reversing the charges. Give the customer appropriate options other than my way or the highway is my opinion. My opinion is that this is being totally bungled by SGC and this will be the last they see of my money.

[nolemmings]

Well, at least you can take comfort in knowing they can't grade S74 silks worth a damn in the first place

Originally Posted by kmac32

Just looked through my S74 silks and 2 were encapsulated without the plastic sleeve the SGC person was talking about. In my opinion, these 2 cards look fine and maybe even better than the others. Unless they can prove to me that this helps preserve the card better, there is absolutely no need to do this other than to take money from my bank account. Have emailed them about encapsulating without the additional plastic and reversing the charges. Give the customer appropriate options other than my way or the highway is my opinion. My opinion is that this is being totally bungled by SGC and this will be the last they see of my money.

[kmac32]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

Well, at least you can take comfort in knowing they can't grade S74 silks worth a damn in the first place

True. And they definitely need to work on their customer service.

[Mozzie22]

When I first looked into getting silks graded years ago only one company would even grade them and it wasn't SGC or PSA. It was these guys...

[kmac32]

Originally Posted by Mozzie22

When I first looked into getting silks graded years ago only one company would even grade them and it wasn't SGC or PSA. It was these guys...

Truthfully, those look good. I may pull my entire SGC order from them over this and they will get nothing from me. Will give them 24 hours to get their act together or I am done. Definitely standing my ground.

[Hankphenom]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

Well, at least you can take comfort in knowing they can't grade S74 silks worth a damn in the first place

IMO, it's a fools errand to try and grade them, just too many variables. S74s, B-18s, BF2s, pins, and other oddball sets, are memorabilia, unlike cards with their standardization, and their value should hinge entirely on what a buyer is willing to pay for what he sees, not on some subjective "grade" another person decides to give it. I can see slabbing them for authenticity, maybe, but if you don't know enough to recognize fakes of these things, why are you collecting them?

[kmac32]

Originally Posted by Hankphenom

IMO, it's a fools errand to try and grade them, just too many variables. S74s, B-18s, BF2s, pins, and other oddball sets, are memorabilia, unlike cards with their standardization, and their value should hinge entirely on what a buyer is willing to pay for what he sees, not on some subjective "grade" another person decides to give it. I can see slabbing them for authenticity, maybe, but if you don't know enough to recognize fakes of these things, why are you collecting them?

Reason for slabbing is not the grade, it is about protecting the cards. I know a real S74 when I see one. Will get them slabbed elsewhere other than SGC.

[BillyCoxDodgers3B]

Originally Posted by kmac32

Reason for slabbing is not the grade, it is about protecting the cards. I know a real S74 when I see one. Will get them slabbed elsewhere other than SGC.

If you truly just want to protect your cards, why not reach out to any of the grading companies to see if they will encapsulate without the grade/flip? I know PSA used to to this for next to nothing (I think you needed to do it in volume, though).