Lou Gehrig underrated?

chadeast · #1 05-25-2021, 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rats60

Gehrig .340/.447/.632 OPS+ 179
Foxx . 325/.428/.609 OPS+ 160

For those that like WAR
Gehrig 114.1 in 17 seasons with only 14 full seasons Those 14 full seasons Gehrig had 113.8 WAR or 8.12 WAR per season.

Foxx 93.9 in 20 seasons. Foxx's best 14 seasons averaged 6.7 WAR.

Gehrig was also a monster in the postseason with 6 WS wins in 7 tries hitting . 361/.483/.731.

It really isn't close. Collectors want to collect the best. For prewar it is Wagner, Cobb, Ruth and Gehrig. Tier 2 players are going to trail behind badly.

No one was arguing that Foxx was better than Gehrig. I think we all agree that Gehrig was clearly better, and the best 1B of all time. The question was which one of them was more underrated.

Exhibitman · #2 05-25-2021, 06:02 PM

One nice way to compare players of varied careers is to look at 7 year peak WAR:

Gehrig 68.1
Pujols 61.7
Foxx 58.5

The rest are substantially below these three.

Top 3 in WAR for 1B are Gehrig, Pujols and Foxx.

No one can really contest Gehrig's status as the GOAT, though I do not agree that Foxx is not a first tier HOFer; the #3 guy has to be.

I guess the question is more whether Foxx cards are undervalued based on his place in baseball history. Of course, that question assumes that card values correlate directly with on-field performance, which is not always the case. Beloved and iconic status can come from other sources besides just stats (hello, Nolan Ryan, #24 in WAR; Mel Ott and Frank Robinson have better career WAR than Roberto Clemente; guess which right-fielder is on a stamp?).

egri · #3 05-25-2021, 06:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

Mel Ott and Frank Robinson have better career WAR than Roberto Clemente; guess which right-fielder is on a stamp?).

Mel Ott has a stamp as well: https://www.mysticstamp.com/Products...ates/4082/USA/

rats60 · #4 05-25-2021, 06:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chadeast

No one was arguing that Foxx was better than Gehrig. I think we all agree that Gehrig was clearly better, and the best 1B of all time. The question was which one of them was more underrated.

I don't think Foxx is underrated at all. Depending on if you consider Stan Musial a 1B or not, Foxx is widely considered #2 or #3 all time at 1b. Johnny Mize and Hank Greenberg are underrated, not Foxx.

As far as card values, people are drawn to the top few names. Players down the list are going to increase in value much slower. I don't think Foxx cards are undervalued at all. In 1933 Goudey after Ruth and Gehrig (and Lajoie) comes Foxx, Hornsby and Dean. He isn't like Eddie Collins who sells for less than many lesser players in t206.

chadeast · #5 05-25-2021, 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rats60

I don't think Foxx is underrated at all. Depending on if you consider Stan Musial a 1B or not, Foxx is widely considered #2 or #3 all time at 1b. Johnny Mize and Hank Greenberg are underrated, not Foxx.

As far as card values, people are drawn to the top few names. Players down the list are going to increase in value much slower. I don't think Foxx cards are undervalued at all. In 1933 Goudey after Ruth and Gehrig (and Lajoie) comes Foxx, Hornsby and Dean. He isn't like Eddie Collins who sells for less than many lesser players in t206.

I can only speak to 33/34 Goudeys, but I agree with you. He's not underrated and priced pretty much right where he should be.

Tao_Moko · #6 05-25-2021, 06:49 PM

One of the best.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Most underrated pre-war set?	luciobar1980	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	66	08-14-2019 10:03 AM
overrated and underrated	Touch'EmAll	Watercooler Talk- ALL sports talk	25	09-24-2012 01:26 PM
Most Underrated Player of All-Time??	smokeyjoewood	Hockey, Olympic, Auto Racing And All Other Cards	11	03-01-2011 08:35 AM
Most Underrated Set	Archive	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	19	08-12-2005 07:08 AM
most underrated moment	Archive	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	2	10-26-2002 08:32 PM