Let's talk about Hall of Fame candidates who have been "neglected"

Peter_Spaeth · #1 07-04-2021, 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike D.

Agree Murphy being inducted wouldn’t keep me up at night.

I mean Baines WAR was only 38.7, and WAR7 only 21.4. Plus, he played forever.

He has to be the most underserving electee in recent memory. Obviously some personal politics there.

Mike D. · #2 07-04-2021, 08:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

He has to be the most underserving electee in recent memory. Obviously some personal politics there.

Clearly�the interesting thing is that it harkens back to the bad old days of the vets committee�you know, before the HOF got bad.

McGriff seems solid and likely to make it eventually - if he does, do we need to re-examine guys like Will Clark, Hernandez, and Olerud? And do Votto and Helton go in too?

G1911 · #3 07-04-2021, 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike D.

Clearly�the interesting thing is that it harkens back to the bad old days of the vets committee�you know, before the HOF got bad.

McGriff seems solid and likely to make it eventually - if he does, do we need to re-examine guys like Will Clark, Hernandez, and Olerud? And do Votto and Helton go in too?

I think Keith Hernandez and John Olerud are clear No's, though they were very good players and Olerud in particular is very underrated.

Will Clark is a real candidate. Sabrmetrics has been very kind to him, 56.5 WAR, 137 career OPS+, and he finished above .300. His relative lack of home runs for a 1B in the home run era hurts him. He does not 'feel' like a HOFer, but he's really not a bad pick.

Helton cleared 60 WAR, 133 OPS+ both of which account for the extremely favorable conditions he player in. He too is borderline to me, I suspect he will eventually make it.

Votto I would vote for at this point, 7 OBP crowns, 147 OPS+. A couple more years of good-not-great production would really help his counting stats.

Other 1B:
Mattingly is a real candidate, but just like Murphy. Short peak that was very good but not historically great, and so I think he falls short.

Hodges is a good candidate, his OPS+ is a bit low at 120, he has some counting stats, the connection to a mythologized team, and I think his managing works to his credit too, leading the 1968 Mets is worth a lot, taking a team that shouldn't go that far all the way is a credit to a manager. I am surprised he is not in, but I would probably not vote for him purely on his career as a 1B, he's hall of very good to me.

I think Carlos Delgado should have gotten serious consideration. I think I end up at "No" for him, but he should not have fallen off the ballot immediately his first year and I think merited a serious discussion. 138 OPS+, 473 dingers. His WAR is slaughtered by his defense.

Peter_Spaeth · #4 07-04-2021, 09:06 PM

I don't see Helton. I think Walker just made it despite the Coors Field thing but I don't see it happening twice.

I don't see Will Clark, to me quintessential Hall of Very Good.

Hernandez and Olerud, no way, agree with you. I don't even understand the support for Hernandez.

Delgado, yeah, interesting case, so is Beltran. Both feel like Dawson to me.

Votto, meh, not even 2000 hits yet, not feeling the love. He doesn't do very well on Baseball Reference metrics either.

Mike D. · #5 07-04-2021, 09:13 PM

With 70 WAR and 434 career homers, I think Beltran makes it. Not first ballot or anything, but he�ll get in.

Peter_Spaeth · #6 07-04-2021, 09:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike D.

With 70 WAR and 434 career homers, I think Beltran makes it. Not first ballot or anything, but he�ll get in.

He may get punished a bit for the scandal, but yes.

Mike D. · #7 07-04-2021, 09:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

He may get punished a bit for the scandal, but yes.

Perhaps, but I�m not sure this scandal has that much staying power, as the fired managers (beyond Beltran) both got re-hired a year after being banned.

G1911 · #8 07-04-2021, 09:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I don't see Helton. I think Walker just made it despite the Coors Field thing but I don't see it happening twice.

I don't see Will Clark, to me quintessential Hall of Very Good.

Hernandez and Olerud, no way, agree with you. I don't even understand the support for Hernandez.

Delgado, yeah, interesting case, so is Beltran.

Votto, meh, not even 2000 hits yet, not feeling the love.

I think Helton will end up in, only because of Larry Walker. I think he will get elected his tenth year or by an era committee at some point.

Beltran never 'felt like' a Hall of Famer to me, but his counting stats accumulated to where I thought his career value was going to put him in. No idea what happens now that his career ends in scandal. Will be interesting to see. I thought Lance Berkman from that Astro's team deserved a serious look as well, not saying he should be a yes but he merited much more than 1.2% of the vote and immediately disappearing from the ballot. Sabrmetrics have been kind to him as well.

Votto is heavily benefited by Sabrmetrics and walking constantly. As more and more of the writers adopt this mindset, I think he will end up making it assuming he doesn't hang on too long and kill his career rate stats. 18th in War, 9th in WAR 7, 15th in JAWS among 1B with everyone higher in the HOF, active or a steroid guy. I'm okay with him getting in, I'd probably vote for him on the strength of his OPS and On Base crowns.

Peter_Spaeth · #9 07-04-2021, 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by G1911

I think Helton will end up in, only because of Larry Walker. I think he will get elected his tenth year or by an era committee at some point.

Beltran never 'felt like' a Hall of Famer to me, but his counting stats accumulated to where I thought his career value was going to put him in. No idea what happens now that his career ends in scandal. Will be interesting to see. I thought Lance Berkman from that Astro's team deserved a serious look as well, not saying he should be a yes but he merited much more than 1.2% of the vote and immediately disappearing from the ballot. Sabrmetrics have been kind to him as well.

Votto is heavily benefited by Sabrmetrics and walking constantly. As more and more of the writers adopt this mindset, I think he will end up making it assuming he doesn't hang on too long and kill his career rate stats. 18th in War, 9th in WAR 7, 15th in JAWS among 1B with everyone higher in the HOF, active or a steroid guy. I'm okay with him getting in, I'd probably vote for him on the strength of his OPS and On Base crowns.

His productive career seems to have ended at age 33. He's already been hanging around doing very little for 4 years IMO. Counting numbers still matter to some extent and at a little over 300 HR and probably a little over 2000 hits when all is said and done, doesn't feel like an obvious HOFer to me.

Peter_Spaeth · #10 07-04-2021, 09:24 PM

Even with Coors, Helton did very little after age 30.

Mozzie22 · #11 07-05-2021, 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I don't see Helton. I think Walker just made it despite the Coors Field thing but I don't see it happening twice.

I don't see Will Clark, to me quintessential Hall of Very Good.

Hernandez and Olerud, no way, agree with you. I don't even understand the support for Hernandez.

Delgado, yeah, interesting case, so is Beltran. Both feel like Dawson to me.

Votto, meh, not even 2000 hits yet, not feeling the love. He doesn't do very well on Baseball Reference metrics either.

Keith Hernandez is the greatest defensive first baseman in MLB history. Period.

Peter_Spaeth · #12 07-05-2021, 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mozzie22

Keith Hernandez is the greatest defensive first baseman in MLB history. Period.

I won't argue with that but it doesn't seem to have persuaded many people as he never got more than about 10 percent of the vote.

Kzoo · #13 07-05-2021, 10:30 AM

I personally believe that if Lou Whitaker played for the Yankees his whole career, like he did for the Tigers, he would have already been in. His career WAR of 75.1 is higher than Ryne Sandberg and Roberto Alomar who played during the same era. A career batting average of .276 isn't great and another World Series title with that core group of mid 80's Tigers would have benefitted his argument, as well.

G1911 · #14 07-05-2021, 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kzoo

I personally believe that if Lou Whitaker played for the Yankees his whole career, like he did for the Tigers, he would have already been in. His career WAR of 75.1 is higher than Ryne Sandberg and Roberto Alomar who played during the same era. A career batting average of .276 isn't great and another World Series title with that core group of mid 80's Tigers would have benefitted his argument, as well.

Somewhat ironically, Whitaker�s being a Tiger is now probably an asset. �Trammel�s in, Whitaker should be too� will, I think, now end up putting him in.

Bram99 · #15 07-05-2021, 06:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kzoo

I personally believe that if Lou Whitaker played for the Yankees his whole career, like he did for the Tigers, he would have already been in. His career WAR of 75.1 is higher than Ryne Sandberg and Roberto Alomar who played during the same era. A career batting average of .276 isn't great and another World Series title with that core group of mid 80's Tigers would have benefitted his argument, as well.

Well if Whitaker is in, Randolph is right there too. It's a slippery slope. And I am not saying Randolph should be in...

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Baseball Hall of Fame "Shoebox Treasures" Exhibit	sixpointone	Postwar Baseball Cards Forum (Pre-1980)	1	04-05-2019 04:21 PM
1977 Exhibits "Baseball's Great Hall of Fame"	Bram99	Live Auctions - Only 2-3 open, per member, at once.	1	01-27-2019 10:39 PM
1970 article on "Card Collector's Hall of Fame"	trdcrdkid	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	12	03-04-2016 03:12 PM
SOLD!!!! "HALL of FAME HEROES" COMPLETE 44 CARD SET! Ends Sun 12-8!	GoldenAge50s	Live Auctions - Only 2-3 open, per member, at once.	5	12-08-2013 09:24 PM
2013 Hall of Fame "Special" Induction 7/28...any Net54 members attending?	orator1	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	21	07-28-2013 06:38 PM