1949 Bowman Jackie Roninson - Real or Fake?

[3-2-count]

I don't like the look of the edges on all 4 sides, not to mention the back seems artificially aged. I vote not genuine.

[egri]

I vote fake as well; it seems artificially aged, and the illustration just doesn't look right to me.

[JollyElm]

If it helps the effort, I cobbled together four different graded versions from eBay for comparison purposes...



1949bowmanjackierobinson.jpg

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by JollyElm

If it helps the effort, I cobbled together four different graded versions from eBay for comparison purposes...



Attachment 496723

That actually does help. Thank you! I didn't think '49 Bowman had the dot printing, but I can see that your examples have the dot printing as well. That makes me feel better.

There's one for sale at at local show. The dealer wants $500. In the condition that it's in, I still think it's a $1500-$2000 card. I have the dealers info, so if it does end up being a fake I can go back to him.

Others commented on the back looking artificially agaed. I noticed that too, but I think something may have happened to the back to make it appear like that. It's not like that on the front.

I found some other '49 Bowman here to compare it to and it feels like the other '49 Bowmans. We'll see.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

I was going to be the contrarian who said he liked it. At $500 it's a good thing I don't know where it is, or you'd never get it

[Bigdaddy]

Hard for me to tell from the front, but the back looks bad. My vote is fake.

[skelly423]

I don’t know how to explain it, but certain cards just don’t look right to me. I can’t pinpoint anything specific, but this is one of those cards that doesn’t look right. Without seeing it in hand I’d stay away from this one

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

That actually does help. Thank you! I didn't think '49 Bowman had the dot printing, but I can see that your examples have the dot printing as well. That makes me feel better.



There's one for sale at at local show. The dealer wants $500. In the condition that it's in, I still think it's a $1500-$2000 card. I have the dealers info, so if it does end up being a fake I can go back to him.



Others commented on the back looking artificially agaed. I noticed that too, but I think something may have happened to the back to make it appear like that. It's not like that on the front.



I found some other '49 Bowman here to compare it to and it feels like the other '49 Bowmans. We'll see.

So this dealer. Is he selling all his cards for 1/3 of market prices?

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[JollyElm]

Any updates?

[chalupacollects]

I thin k it is real as registration is off a little on the front. Why would you reprint it that way?