Say What?!? Honus Wagner card on Upcoming (5/21) Pawn Stars?

[ullmandds]

So it was an e104-II wagner...appraised at 50K...in a sgc 1.5 holder. Rick offered 50K...thee guy who inherited it wants 500K.

Appraisal seems bonkers to me.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

So it was an e104-II wagner...appraised at 50K...in a sgc 1.5 holder. Rick offered 50K...thee guy who inherited it wants 500K.

Appraisal seems bonkers to me.

Wasn't it this exact one?:

https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball-c.../50007-80202.s

Sold at Heritage Nov 2018 for 4K.

[ullmandds]

Yes.

[cannonballsun]

Good appraisal, just a little bit off.

[Bestdj777]

Originally Posted by cannonballsun

Good appraisal, just a little bit off.

What’s it worth?

[mrreality68]

Wow that is a big jump in 3 and half years

[Rhotchkiss]

I think I used to own that card- at one point I had 4 e104-IIs (I should post in the hoarding thread!). I recently sold two, both to friends. I don’t recall the price but they were 5 figures and nowhere near $50k.

E104-2 is super rare. It’s a set that celebrates the pirates and honus is THE card of the set. It’s an expensive card for sure, but I would say the card posted there is a $12k-$15k card in this market. Maybe if two people get into a bidding war it goes for a little more (could go less - it’s ugly!!)

[VintageBen]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

So it was an e104-II wagner...appraised at 50K...in a sgc 1.5 holder. Rick offered 50K...thee guy who inherited it wants 500K.

Appraisal seems bonkers to me.

I was watching that episode yesterday...

The guy they brought in was from CSG.

I'd have brought my whole collection into the pawn shop and have him appraise my collection...