August pickups

[V117collector]

Originally Posted by luciobar1980

Psyched about this one on its way to me. Guess the PSA grade:

My guess would be 5 or a 5.5

[luciobar1980]

Originally Posted by V117collector

My guess would be 5 or a 5.5

What makes you guess so low? I think it looks great for a.........

PSA 6

[V117collector]

Originally Posted by luciobar1980

What makes you guess so low? I think it looks great for a.........

PSA 6

The only reason I said 5 or 5.5 is b/c of the touch of wear on the bottom corners. I have no problem if the card is graded a PSA 6, if anything the card is graded accurately. I've seen other cards in similar condition in SGC holders that would grade a 5 or 5.5. I just thought it could be a trick question.

I picked this Mays up not too long ago that I believe is in similar condition. I believe it deserves a higher grade. maybe I should send it off to PSA.

[luciobar1980]

Originally Posted by V117collector

The only reason I said 5 or 5.5 is b/c of the touch of wear on the bottom corners. I have no problem if the card is graded a PSA 6, if anything the card is graded accurately. I've seen other cards in similar condition in SGC holders that would grade a 5 or 5.5. I just thought it could be a trick question.

I picked this Mays up not too long ago that I believe is in similar condition. I believe it deserves a higher grade. maybe I should send it off to PSA.

Yeah your Mays presents nicer than a 5. Just a little Oc towards the bottom, but sharp!