A Fake???? Mantle

[luciobar1980]

Yeah, card looks fine to me.

Annoying but i guess I would just resubmit.. to SGC, personally.

[hockeyhockey]

looks legit and it's centered. crack and re-submit. grading fee is sunk cost and move on.

[NiceDocter]

I would start by submitting the card to PSA in the original holder and see if they can regrade/reslab the card. If its their error it may not cost you anything at all. Good luck..... I hope that card is real because I sure cant see anything wrong with it.

[111gecko]

I agree the card looks real and probably a mistake. If you do a quick check going forward and backwards you can sometimes get an indication if the cards all came in with one submission (eg. a run of 1969s in this case). There appears to be a block of about 15-20 cards in a row "not found in database". I'm not sure if they leave empty certs for future use or what purpose skipping numbers would provide; but it's possible it's an inputting error....
If you send it in as a review and the case hasn't been tampered with; they will need to address it (I would think they would just crack/regrade with new cert).
Good luck!! Give us a follow up when you find out. Thanks.

[1952boyntoncollector]

card looks real to me., i would buy it from someone that had it minus grading costs and shipping and handling etc.

[Johnny T]

Thank you all for your suggestions and counsel...I will keep you posted

[nwobhm]

I would be willing to take it off your hands.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by NiceDocter

I would start by submitting the card to PSA in the original holder and see if they can regrade/reslab the card. If its their error it may not cost you anything at all. Good luck..... I hope that card is real because I sure cant see anything wrong with it.

+1 agree

[Johnny T]

Sorry...card came back as Authentic w/evidence of trimming.