W575-1 Were Never Hand Cut

[ullmandds]

My only w575-1. Been a psa 2 as long as I’ve owned it.

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

My only w575-1. Been a psa 2 as long as I’ve owned it.

Nice card, Pete, but are you sure it is a W575-1, and not a W501-2? Just asking, as I suspect it's a W501-2.

[rhettyeakley]

That Cobb with the grainy image quality is what i referred to as W501-2 in my article, which i feel is a much better description than lumping them into the W575-1 category.

I can go off at length about these issues if anyone is really interested.

[ullmandds]

Thats why I posted as I was unsure. Now I see the border as a give away its w501-2.

[ValKehl]

When I got this W501-2 of WaJo on eBay in 2015, a previous owner had already written the card number "17" in pencil in the upper right corner, perhaps after reading Rhett's OC article.

[Luke]

Funny timing. I just got grades back from a PSA order and they labeled my Lou Gertenrich Max Carey as "e575-1 hand-cut".

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Luke

Funny timing. I just got grades back from a PSA order and they labeled my Lou Gertenrich Max Carey as "e575-1 hand-cut".

I sense the major TPGs are becoming more and more clueless when it comes to pre-War scarcities.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Luke

Funny timing. I just got grades back from a PSA order and they labeled my Lou Gertenrich Max Carey as "e575-1 hand-cut".

Jefferson Burdick would be proud. The biggest grading company now completely fabricating ACC numbers. That and, unless the Gertenrich is trimmed and it probably isn't, they got the hand cut wrong too! A potential 2fer....