A Fake???? Mantle

[steveinphilly]

If you are stuck on a long boring conference call, it might be worth juxtaposing some of the numbers in the PSA search bar to see whether you can find the card. Maybe if they just got two numbers switched, they’d be willing to re-slab it for you for free.

[Bestdj777]

Did you pay cash or by credit card? I agree with the others that nothing looks suspect about the card. If you paid via credit card, you may be able to check your payment history, identify the seller, and see if they submitted it themselves and have anything that you can use in arguing with PSA. At the end of the day, it’s annoying but you probably own a legitimate PSA 5 card so it is what it is.

[Kutcher55]

It’s fine. It’s obviously a screw up by PSA - they recorded it wrong in their database. As usual the Collins guy with the correct take.

[Johnny T]

And it ain't good....cracked the case, sent to SGC who said it is Authentic...lesson learned...hopefully!

Thanks for all of your replies. JT

[Rad_Hazard]

Originally Posted by Johnny T

And it ain't good....cracked the case, sent to SGC who said it is Authentic...lesson learned...hopefully!

Thanks for all of your replies. JT

With their new Authentic grades did they state why it was only graded as Authentic?

[Bigdaddy]

So you have one company that says it's only 'Authentic', another that says it is a 5/10 and several collectors here with still different opinions.

Who's right??

Isn't that the real problem with all the TPGs? They are just giving you an opinion, which can (and does) change on a daily basis.