Who is the greatest player of all time by position?

[Carter08]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I like this list, but W Johnson or Clemens over Young, and Bench over Piazza.

I see the arguments for bench and piazza and as a Mets fan I want piazza (if not carter). That said, I give it to yogi all day. His war is oddly low though - doesn’t make sense to me.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by Carter08

I see the arguments for bench and piazza and as a Mets fan I want piazza (if not carter). That said, I give it to yogi all day. His war is oddly low though - doesn’t make sense to me.

Carter does great by WAR if I recall, it seemed to overrate him and underrate Yogi a bit. I would rank Bench and Yogi 1-2.