The Top 10 Hoplites of the The Peloponnesian Wars

[G1911]

I must cast my vote for my main man, Thucydides, as the #1. I know there’s some hot takes on here:

1. Thucydides
2. Brasidas
3. Alcibiades
4. Pericles
5. Nicias
6. Cleon
7. Gylippus
8. Lysander
9. Antiochus
10. Mindarus

[boneheadandrube]

Originally Posted by G1911

I must cast my vote for my main man, Thucydides, as the #1. I know there’s some hot takes on here:

1. Thucydides
2. Brasidas
3. Alcibiades
4. Pericles
5. Nicias
6. Cleon
7. Gylippus
8. Lysander
9. Antiochus
10. Mindarus

11. Xerxes

[G1911]

Originally Posted by boneheadandrube

11. Xerxes

I think Persian Kings of Kings from before the war just can’t rack up enough Greek WAR to crack the top 10, but what a talent Xerxes I was.

[EddieP]

Originally Posted by G1911

I must cast my vote for my main man, Thucydides, as the #1. I know there’s some hot takes on here:

1. Thucydides
2. Brasidas
3. Alcibiades
4. Pericles
5. Nicias
6. Cleon
7. Gylippus
8. Lysander
9. Antiochus
10. Mindarus

I’d rank Pericles as #1 since he was the General. Granted Thucydides wrote about it but I would rank him somewhere near the middle. But how can you leave out Socrates?

“An earlier post considered the Melian massacre and the Athenian conduct of war during the Peloponnesian War (link). Since we know that Socrates served as an armored infantry soldier during that war (a hoplite), it is reasonable to ask whether Socrates would have carried out atrocious orders involving the execution of prisoners, enslavement of women and children, and other acts of retaliation and punishment against the enemies of Athens.
In particular, would Socrates the hoplite have obeyed the order to slaughter the innocent? Ancient historian Mark Anderson offers a detailed analysis of the known context of Athenian warfare and Socrates' military history, and concludes that Socrates did not express moral opposition to these acts of war (Mark Anderson, "Socrates as Hoplite"; link). Anderson argues at length that Socrates was a hoplite during exactly these kinds of campaigns of retaliation, and that he never expressed any moral objection to them. Against the arguments of Gregory Vlastos and other scholars of Athenian philosophy, Anderson argues that the historical record of Socrates’ military service is fairly clear, and it is evident that his participation was voluntary, courageous, extended, and supportive. Anderson argues on the basis of these facts that Socrates did not offer moral objections to this dimension of Athenian military strategy.“

https://understandingsociety.blogspo...s-hoplite.html

[packs]

Athens had a prospect by the name of Testicles during the early part of the war. Everyone thought he might win rookie of the war but a groin injury took him out.

[Eric72]

Originally Posted by packs

Athens had a prospect by the name of Testicles during the early part of the war. Everyone thought he might win rookie of the war but a groin injury took him out.

It took a pair of brass one to post that.

I wonder how many people just skimmed right by and didn’t read it.

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by Eric72

I wonder how many people just skimmed right by and didn’t read it.

I groined when I read it.

Brian

[Tom S.]

Originally Posted by packs

Athens had a prospect by the name of Testicles during the early part of the war. Everyone thought he might win rookie of the war but a groin injury took him out.

That's nuts!

[G1911]

Originally Posted by EddieP

I’d rank Pericles as #1 since he was the General. Granted Thucydides wrote about it but I would rank him somewhere near the middle. But how can you leave out Socrates?

“An earlier post considered the Melian massacre and the Athenian conduct of war during the Peloponnesian War (link). Since we know that Socrates served as an armored infantry soldier during that war (a hoplite), it is reasonable to ask whether Socrates would have carried out atrocious orders involving the execution of prisoners, enslavement of women and children, and other acts of retaliation and punishment against the enemies of Athens.
In particular, would Socrates the hoplite have obeyed the order to slaughter the innocent? Ancient historian Mark Anderson offers a detailed analysis of the known context of Athenian warfare and Socrates' military history, and concludes that Socrates did not express moral opposition to these acts of war (Mark Anderson, "Socrates as Hoplite"; link). Anderson argues at length that Socrates was a hoplite during exactly these kinds of campaigns of retaliation, and that he never expressed any moral objection to them. Against the arguments of Gregory Vlastos and other scholars of Athenian philosophy, Anderson argues that the historical record of Socrates’ military service is fairly clear, and it is evident that his participation was voluntary, courageous, extended, and supportive. Anderson argues on the basis of these facts that Socrates did not offer moral objections to this dimension of Athenian military strategy.“

https://understandingsociety.blogspo...s-hoplite.html

This really comes down to a debate on how we value value. I ranked (totally didn’t just randomly jot the first 10 leaders of the war that came to me…. I would never do that!) them based upon their contributions to the war and only the war, not their broader contributions to humanity. If we’re ranking on lifetime net WAR, I would also put Socrates #1, with 365.36482847288483 points by my advanced math whose formula I cannot share for reasons.

My formula also shows that Socrates-Plato-Aristotle is the most valuable direct lineage teaching line in world history with a hair over 1,000 WAR.

[Peter_Spaeth]

I thought Thucydides was exiled for his military failures. Odd choice for #1.

[G1911]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I thought Thucydides was exiled for his military failures. Odd choice for #1.

He was scapegoated by the fake news.

[wolf441]

The JD Drew of ancient Greece...

[frankbmd]

Originally Posted by boneheadandrube

11. Xerxes

Originally Posted by G1911

I think Persian Kings of Kings from before the war just can’t rack up enough Greek WAR to crack the top 10, but what a talent Xerxes I was.

Neither a Spartan or an Athenian and certainly above the Hoplite pay grade, Xerxes was on the wrong side of the fence for this thread.

[Michael B]

Originally Posted by G1911

I must cast my vote for my main man, Thucydides, as the #1. I know there’s some hot takes on here:

1. Thucydides
2. Brasidas
3. Alcibiades
4. Pericles
5. Nicias
6. Cleon
7. Gylippus
8. Lysander
9. Antiochus
10. Mindarus

As part of my senior thesis class 'Works of Great Historians' we had to read part of "History of the Peloponnesian War" by Thucydides. Fortunately, it was the gravy class for history majors and you did not have to write a thesis. Show up for the class and participate in the discussions.

[ALBB]

I find this quite funny and amusing !

[gonzo]

No love for Xenophon?
I know he only came in at the very end of the Dead Greek Era, and he did his best work over in the Persian Central League, but he should be in the Hall at least as an Ambassador of the Phalanx.

[obiwan1129]

Originally Posted by gonzo

No love for Xenophon?
I know he only came in at the very end of the Dead Greek Era, and he did his best work over in the Persian Central League, but he should be in the Hall at least as an Ambassador of the Phalanx.

No mention of Cyrus either?

Pfffttt