Best George Sisler card for HOF collection?

[paul]

I agree with the W503. If you like the 1921 Exhibit pose, you should also consider the V100, which I think has the same pose. Another nice one is the M101-5 rookie, listing him as a pitcher.

[Exhibitman]

[Vintagedeputy]

I like the 1921 Oxford Confectionary set.

[Yoda]

I would go with the Standard Biscuit.

[mikemcgrail]

1925 Turf Cigarettes could be an interesting option

[terjung]

I really like the V89 William Paterson


The M101-6 Felix Mendelsohn would be my runner up.

[Belfast1933]

Originally Posted by terjung

I really like the V89 William Paterson


The M101-6 Felix Mendelsohn would be my runner up.

Me too.. just searched EBay and couldn’t find any, current or past sales. That usually tells me this is a rare ($$$) issue.

That true? I like the look - looks like a “real” baseball card to me.

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by terjung

I really like the V89 William Paterson

Brian, you aren't alone - great card!

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by terjung

Look, in the studio, with the bat...It's Superman!

[h2oya311]

Originally Posted by paul

I agree with the W503. If you like the 1921 Exhibit pose, you should also consider the V100, which I think has the same pose. Another nice one is the M101-5 rookie, listing him as a pitcher.

Here’s the V100 that Paul mentioned. Not as nice as the exhibit, IMO, despite being the same image.



And I think that V89 is STUNNING. Seriously. Although incredibly rare, if I didn’t care about the whole “rookie” / “pre-rookie” thing, I’d hold out for one for sure.

Here’s my “placeholder”, but likely one-of-one, so don’t bother holding out to get it:

[G1911]

Originally Posted by h2oya311

Here’s the V100 that Paul mentioned. Not as nice as the exhibit, IMO, despite being the same image.



And I think that V89 is STUNNING. Seriously. Although incredibly rare, if I didn’t care about the whole “rookie” / “pre-rookie” thing, I’d hold out for one for sure.

Here’s my “placeholder”, but likely one-of-one, so don’t bother holding out to get it:

What is this second likely one of one card? Don’t recognize it but love this image. Very cool

[Leon]

A W575-1 (blank back of course) might be a less expensive alternative to the E121, though neither one in average condition will be too expensive (low hundred(s)). Pardon the other cards....