I Don't Tout Too Many Auction Items But..1890-92 Ryder Studio Cabinet Cy Young

[robertsmithnocure]

Originally Posted by JustinD

I keep hearing this but it seems highly unlikely it would be from him not playing for Cleveland, only debate could be date. The other known Young Ryder Cabinet is from a team set done in 1891. How do we know the date? Because the photo was used in the rare 1891 Spiders composite schedule.

How do we know that the cabinet of Young in uniform was not produced in 1890? Assuming that the 1891 Cleveland composite/schedule was produced some time prior to the 1891 season, could the image have been taken sometime during their 1890 season?

To me, Young looks a bit older in his suit pose than in his uniform version.

[JustinD]

Originally Posted by robertsmithnocure

How do we know that the cabinet of Young in uniform was not produced in 1890? Assuming that the 1891 Cleveland composite/schedule was produced some time prior to the 1891 season, could the image have been taken sometime during their 1890 season?

To me, Young looks a bit older in his suit pose than in his uniform version.

Well you are surpassing my full knowledge of it. As the cabinets in that series comprise I believe the full team, perhaps the checklist has some players that narrow it specifically. Perhaps someone with more knowledge on all the known players can chime in.

[robertsmithnocure]

Originally Posted by JustinD

Well you are surpassing my full knowledge of it. As the cabinets in that series comprise I believe the full team, perhaps the checklist has some players that narrow it specifically. Perhaps someone with more knowledge on all the known players can chime in.

Yes, above my pay grade too. I was just thinking out loud.

It seems to me that the latest that the uniform pose was take was early 1891, before the calendar was issued, but does anything preclude it from being from 1890?

It looks like whoever produced the calendars reused many of the pictures from their 1891 version for their 1892 one.

[JustinD]

Originally Posted by robertsmithnocure

Yes, above my pay grade too. I was just thinking out loud.

It seems to me that the latest that the uniform pose was take was early 1891, before the calendar was issued, but does anything preclude it from being from 1890?

It looks like whoever produced the calendars reused many of the pictures from their 1891 version for their 1892 one.

Well, I completely understand your line of thought. That’s why I had added in the prior post that that the only true question in my mind could be date. As for it being prior to his time on Cleveland or completely unaffiliated with the team with the other strong connective links, well I think those doubts are a stretch.

[oldjudge]

Other than the date scrawled on the mount, how do we know the suit pose is from 1890? That date could have been written by anyone at any time and could easily be wrong. I have see plenty of cabinets where the player pictured is misidentified by a written in name. If people can get the subject wrong they can surely get the date wrong.
Based on the 1891 schedule piece I agree that the uniform cabinet is certainly from early-1891 or late-1890.

[boneheadandrube]

Could probably use the cabinet mount to date it as the print styles/formats for the uniform and street versions are different. Would need other examples to compare etc.

[oldjudge]

Yes, or dates photographer that address.