PSA card mysteriously damaged in mail.

[Eric72]

Of course, there's the possibility the buyer did something to the slabbed card after they opened the package.

That was my first thought. Intact packaging plus cracked slab often equals recipient who did something innocent-but-clumsy or inanely stupid.

[Mark17]

Originally Posted by Eric72

Of course, there's the possibility the buyer did something to the slabbed card after they opened the package.

That was my first thought. Intact packaging plus cracked slab often equals recipient who did something innocent-but-clumsy or inanely stupid.

If this was the case, in other words, if deception was afoot, I would think the recipient would put some damage on the package to make his story more believable. That's my first thought.

[Eric72]

Originally Posted by Mark17

If this was the case, in other words, if deception was afoot, I would think the recipient would put some damage on the package to make his story more believable. That's my first thought.

I guess that makes sense. I was thinking the intact packaging would make it look like the seller was "clearly at fault" or something like that.