Pete Rose Cards...

[Harliduck]

Originally Posted by jchcollins

I'm not a Rose collector per se. I think he was obviously amazing on the field, and had a drive and persistence that will be matched by only a small fraction of a percent of players. He wasn't the best or even close to it by virtue of sheer physical talent. Like Cobb, he willed himself to be the player he became. So for that, I admire him.

As for the off-the-field stuff, I think at some point the rule of "not knowing your heroes too well" comes into play. Clearly the guy was no saint. But neither was Mickey Mantle, or a host of others. How far does our judgment extend?

As for the '63 rookie card, I was screwed because '63 is my favorite set of the '60's. My bread and butter since I was a kid in the late 80's has been postwar vintage. 1950's - 1980. Regardless of what I think of Rose, the set is not complete without that card. And regardless, to say it's a not huge card in the vintage hobby is just a falsehood. Rose's notorious status at this point makes it an iconic card even if the guy was mostly bad.

So - (horrible timing) this past weekend - I finally picked up the '63 Gonzalez / McMullen / Rose / Weis in an SGC 4 to add to my set. I've owned the card before, but as this was the first time I have really gotten serious on the set building end of things, this one is for keeps. I hope that Pete one way or another is finally at peace now from his turbulent life. Regardless of what you think of him, he was significant.

Congrats on your 63 Rose pick up (or re-pick up) John...your right, none of the noise matters, that card is simply iconic. It was a dream of mine when I was a kid, a card I thought was only a fantasy to own. I covet my own SGC 4 (pictured above) and much like yours, isn't going anywhere. Mine is also my second Rose...I had an SGC 5 first, sold it, regretted it, picked this one up when I was pursuing the set. Congrats!

[jchcollins]

Originally Posted by Harliduck

I had an SGC 5 first, sold it, regretted it, picked this one up when I was pursuing the set. Congrats!

Thanks! I had a PSA 5 before as well, sold it at the beginning of the pandemic for well less than half of what it would go for now. Whoops.

[deweyinthehall]

Given my current pace of set building I should be starting on 1963 by the end of '26 - I am holding out hope that by then, the speculators, gamblers and other rogues will have left the hobby to us collectors and set builders and prices will have come down by 50%.

Or am I being too optimistic?

[jchcollins]

Originally Posted by deweyinthehall

Given my current pace of set building I should be starting on 1963 by the end of '26 - I am holding out hope that by then, the speculators, gamblers and other rogues will have left the hobby to us collectors and set builders and prices will have come down by 50%.

Or am I being too optimistic?

LOL, I hope that every day. I'd love to buy $50 raw Mantle base cards and $15-20 cards of other HOF'ers.

I don't believe in reality this will ever happen. But it's a nice thought anyway.

[REG1976]

1964 Reds Photo Card

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by jchcollins

LOL, I hope that every day. I'd love to buy $50 raw Mantle base cards and $15-20 cards of other HOF'ers.



I don't believe in reality this will ever happen. But it's a nice thought anyway.

I don't know. I think if prices went down 50% I would still spend as much, the cards would just take up twice as much room in my house.

Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk