Babe Ruth Double Signed

David Atkatz · #1 07-13-2025, 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kco

$25,000 is probably the top of the market for 2 Ruth PSA 10 Cuts, which is what this could easily be turned into if so desired.

Again, yes, low quality cuts can be had for 3.5-4k, but you're not finding PSA 10s for under $11-12k per auto at auction. (look at the last few on Heritage for reference)

The fact that it's on the Hotel New York Stationary, which he frequented and is untouched, and was double graded 10 (not sure if most realize the grading premium tacked on of getting a 10 on a vintage Ruth, let alone both autos grading 10 on the same piece.), $23,000 is a premium price but you're not finding a Double signed Gem Mint 10 Ruth signed item anywhere else.

This isn't a piece that's going to lose value, if anything it'll gain over the average Ruth cuts over time as an untouched piece.

Without a doubt, sports autograph collecting has gone to the dogs.
It's a twice signed sheet of hotel stationary, for chrissakes. It's not a letter (which might have interesting baseball content), or a contract (which again is an actual historical artifact with some meaning).
Authentication was bad enough--unless the gods on Mt Olympus (PSA and JSA) provide their imprimatur, don't even try to sell. (And those assholes know less, and have less experience than many collectors.) But now, It has to be graded, too! A 10! A 10!. Now that's worth a $5k premium!
Don't you realize those numbers are totally subjective? Tell me the difference between a 9 signature and a 10 signature. Only difference is the day it was graded, and which teenage "expert" did the grading.
It's just pathetic how collectors have given up all autonomy, and all attempts to actually learn anything, and depend upon faceless, nameless, self-proclaimed experts.
Two signatures. Nothing more. the simplest, most meaningless holograph item you can find.
But it's a 10!

SyrNy1960 · #2 07-14-2025, 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David Atkatz

Without a doubt, sports autograph collecting has gone to the dogs.
It's a twice signed sheet of hotel stationary, for chrissakes. It's not a letter (which might have interesting baseball content), or a contract (which again is an actual historical artifact with some meaning).
Authentication was bad enough--unless the gods on Mt Olympus (PSA and JSA) provide their imprimatur, don't even try to sell. (And those assholes know less, and have less experience than many collectors.) But now, It has to be graded, too! A 10! A 10!. Now that's worth a $5k premium!
Don't you realize those numbers are totally subjective? Tell me the difference between a 9 signature and a 10 signature. Only difference is the day it was graded, and which teenage "expert" did the grading.
It's just pathetic how collectors have given up all autonomy, and all attempts to actually learn anything, and depend upon faceless, nameless, self-proclaimed experts.
Two signatures. Nothing more. the simplest, most meaningless holograph item you can find.
But it's a 10!

After reading your post this morning, I thought to myself, “Man, this guy may need to go to anger management classes.” Then after going back and reading some of your past posts, I thought to myself, “Yup!”

In all seriousness, your post had nothing to do with my comment and looking for thoughts on value, nor did it add anything of positive value to it. It was nothing more than your hateful rant against sports autograph collecting, autograph collectors, and the authenticators (PSA, JSA, etc.).

You see this as “two signatures. Nothing more. the simplest, most meaningless holograph item you can find.” This just goes to show how much you don’t know.

I see this as an awesome piece! Two beautiful authentic Babe Ruth signatures on a single piece of Hotel President New York stationery of the late 1920 / early 1930’s. How many items have you seen with two Babe Ruth signatures (PSA 10) on it? Waiting, waiting…Crickets! And yes, contracts are cool, but they are not signed Babe Ruth.

Next time, before thinking about posting another hateful rant against sports autograph collecting, autograph collectors, and the authenticators (PSA, JSA, etc.) on someone’s post, maybe just consider creating your own posts about what you hate and then rant all you want.

Yes, I don’t appreciate your post!

P.S. I did find this somewhat funny on your post “FS: 1998 Yankees Team-Signed Baseball - Absolutely guaranteed to pass PSA or JSA, or full refund.”

David Atkatz · #3 07-14-2025, 05:56 PM

Pretty soon you'll all be out of luck.
I heard that PSA will introduce--for very special customers only--a grading scale that goes to...
11!

(With apologies to Nigel Tufnel.)

Kco · #4 07-16-2025, 09:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SyrNy1960

After reading your post this morning, I thought to myself, �Man, this guy may need to go to anger management classes.� Then after going back and reading some of your past posts, I thought to myself, �Yup!�

In all seriousness, your post had nothing to do with my comment and looking for thoughts on value, nor did it add anything of positive value to it. It was nothing more than your hateful rant against sports autograph collecting, autograph collectors, and the authenticators (PSA, JSA, etc.).

You see this as �two signatures. Nothing more. the simplest, most meaningless holograph item you can find.� This just goes to show how much you don�t know.

I see this as an awesome piece! Two beautiful authentic Babe Ruth signatures on a single piece of Hotel President New York stationery of the late 1920 / early 1930�s. How many items have you seen with two Babe Ruth signatures (PSA 10) on it? Waiting, waiting�Crickets! And yes, contracts are cool, but they are not signed Babe Ruth.

Next time, before thinking about posting another hateful rant against sports autograph collecting, autograph collectors, and the authenticators (PSA, JSA, etc.) on someone�s post, maybe just consider creating your own posts about what you hate and then rant all you want.

Yes, I don�t appreciate your post!

P.S. I did find this somewhat funny on your post �FS: 1998 Yankees Team-Signed Baseball - Absolutely guaranteed to pass PSA or JSA, or full refund.�

He is always this way, and he's the biggest expert of all experts. Ignore the grumpy people on this forum, it's a lot easier. Probably also thinks the stock market should be the same price as it was in 1995, houses should cost what they did in 1980, etc. The reality is the market bears what it bears, and has and will continue to pay premiums on high graded (autographs or cards) examples.

Thats like saying a 52 Mantle that's graded a 2 should be the same as one graded a 6 since its "subjective"

Hankphenom · #5 07-18-2025, 03:08 PM

What a cool and unusual piece! I'm guessing that someone wrote the Babe asking for two autographs on the same sheet, top and bottom for some purpose, and decided this was better when he got it so he left it alone.

David Atkatz · #6 07-19-2025, 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kco

Thats like saying a 52 Mantle that's graded a 2 should be the same as one graded a 6 since its "subjective"

You're not all that quick on the uptake, are you?
It's obvious that there's a condition difference between a "2" and a "6." But that difference is subjective. Do you really think that every single grader, given that "6" raw, will grade it a 6? That no one at all will grade it a 7? Or a 5?
If you believe that, say hi to the tooth fairy next time you see her.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
FS Babe Ruth Double Signed Check $13K	Donscards	Autographs & Game Used B/S/T	0	11-08-2022 09:26 AM
WTB 1950's - 1960's Signed Trading cards Mrs. Babe Ruth Or Ruth's daughter	tkd	Autographs & Game Used B/S/T	1	08-21-2020 09:38 PM
Babe Ruth Signed Baseball (OAL) w/ JSA LOA - Displays as Single Signed! on eBay!	Billyscards	Ebay, Auction and other Venues Announcement- B/S/T	1	07-12-2017 03:50 PM
Babe Ruth Signed Letter Rare and Signed.com COA	thetruthisoutthere	Autograph Forum- Primarily Sports	7	07-28-2013 09:02 PM
The Babe Ruth Story Signed by Ruth and Author - 1st Edition	loubrown	Baseball Memorabilia B/S/T	2	09-29-2012 11:07 AM