UPDATED - My turn to complain about PSA - Davidson T206

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by Ludington1

Well the Davidson PSA 2 made me mad enough that I put it in a batch of other cards and sent them to SCG in early August. Got my shipping notification today and now I feel like it got the right grading. Very happy with this result.

"Damn the torpedos, full speed ahead."

[JollyElm]

Originally Posted by Yoda

"Damn the torpedos, full speed ahead."

With all of the arguing on Net54, there is one thing we can all agree on.
No thread is ever complete without a Rear Admiral David Farragut reference thrown into it!!!

[perezfan]

Smart move…. Glad you got the grade it deserved.

It’s just too bad collectors have come to rely so heavily on the idiotic flip for justification (when our own set of eyes almost always knows better).

[Ludington1]

Originally Posted by perezfan

Smart move…. Glad you got the grade it deserved.

It’s just too bad collectors have come to rely so heavily on the idiotic flip for justification (when our own set of eyes almost always knows better).

I agree… my main driver for grading any of them is for the encapsulation as I’m doing this with my 13 year-old son, so I like the idea of them being sealed and safe for as long as he wants to keep them. But the PSA2 on this card just made me mad.

[sacentaur]

And here’s a dirty, fugly card, 2025 PSA graded.

[toledo_mudhen]

"FUGLY" for sure! 4 is a pretty generous grade (IMHO)

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by toledo_mudhen

"FUGLY" for sure! 4 is a pretty generous grade (IMHO)

Yup.... seen tons of 2s that look much nicer than that 4. PSA is about as consistent as Angel Hernandez' strike zone.