N172 Old Judge Population Reports

[Archive]

Posted By: Joe_G.

Thanks for the thumbs up.

OK, to answer a couple questions, the PSA qualifiers were treated as 2 point deductions. For example, for the cards that were 7 with a qualifier, we reduced it to a 5 for the averaging calculations and when comparing against others for the highest graded example.

I actually haven't collected all that many OJs, I collect what I can afford which amounts to somewhere north of 50 examples, almost all Detroits. I've crossed over several PSA cards with varying results. I'd say evenly returned at equal, lower, and higher grades by SGC.

I could be wrong, but I thought several on the Goudey thread indicated that SGC was the tougher grade, will look at that again later. Or perhaps Jim can compare/contrast the two before I get a chance.

Regards,
Joe G.