I agree with Joe Orlando here

[Archive]

Posted By: Josh K.

Martin -

The problem is not that PSA didnt catch the alterations the second time the card was graded (ok, well, that is a problem since the basis behind the service is their ability to authenticate cards) but that PSA did nothing about it after being confronted with the evidence. It is clear from the listing that Orlando was provided scans of both cards. He said he couldnt determine that they were the same card and did nothing. I guarantee you that had this been an SGC graded card and they failed to catch the alteration, upon being presented the evidence of the mistake, they would have bought the card from the owner and taken it out of circulation - I say this because specific instances when they have done so have been discussed on this board many times.