Can we say something positive about PSA or is it always terrible?

[Archive]

Posted By: JohnKalafarski

Since '33 Goudeys are my major interest, I prefer PSA to SGC. SGC is weak on corners and I like strong corners. SGC holders highlight corners, inviting the eye to behold the frayed corner. One of the honchos at SGC told me that, for them, centering is almost everything. I like pack fresh, original gloss over better centering. For me, eye appeal is the name of the game. The PSA holder is more aesthetically pleasing. I agree with Barry that PSA is too big and more prone to error. I've always found their customer service excellent. They fetch higher prices too. SGC has found a niche in early dead-ball, not my area of concern.