old judge rarity.... or not

[Archive]

Posted By: JudgeDred2

When it comes to Old Judge cards the population reports of PSA aren't really indicative of anything. You'll find a higher concentration of HOF players encapsulated, does that mean all the "nobody" players are rare or scarce. I'm willing to go out on a limb here and guess that most Old Judge cards are not encapsulated. If people are paying more for Old Judge cards based on the population reports then they are making uninformed purchases. The grading companies only provide the name of the player. They don't break down the cards by pose or team. It's kind of like the T206 cards. The grading companies really never took the time to break down the backs of the cards by manufacturer or factory number.