Share your Cincinnati Reds cards

[onlychild]

A 70 candy lid and an 82 blackless




Kevin

[Griffins]

As long as you're sifting through your Reds cards, can anybody confirm the existence of the card checklisted in the 1940 Cincinnati Reds Team Issue as
(35) in the Standard Catalog . . . "Debt of Gratitude to Wm. Koeh Co."?

Otherwise it gets de-listed.

Thank you Bob- I've been searching for any evidence of this card for years, and not only have never seen one but can't see anyway it could've existed.
Here's a full press sheet of the '40 W711-2 set

[Bob Lemke]

some of the other the cards listed as #30-34. Seems the checklist may have doubled up on them. Do yo have scans of the back of the sheet in that area?

[Griffins]

[Griffins]

Bob- I've got the variations in single cards as well, if you need scans of those are bigger scans of the sheet let me know.
It seems pretty easy to see where they overprinted the variations on the 2nd print run. But I can't see where they would cut out a card and strip in the "debt of gratitude" card.
I've bought about a dozen complete sets and they seem pretty evenly split between the 2 sets of variation- if the "debt" card was in one press run or another it would seem to pop up at some point, and another card would be in shorter supply, but that has never happened. And the pops on the other cards are consistant, while the debt card has never been graded by either PSA or SGC.

[toppcat]

Amazing scans-wow!