Doyle on eBay

[FrankWakefield]

It looks to me that someone sent a Doyle in to PSA to be graded, got it graded, then somewhere along the line someone worked their way into the slab and swapped cards. I think that is somewhat more likely than PSA completely missing the paper loss, or rub. (somewhat... not definitely).

Someone should know how and be able to get that number off of the slip, and see what card PSA thinks it is... I'm thinking a normal Doyle.

[scottglevy]

This listing was very funny and quite entertaining to me. 99% sure that the lister made a mistake (or is trying to intentionally mislead) ... but there is always that 1% chance that someone decided to ruin a $250k card and turn it into a $250 card.

Hope that someone doesn't pay too much for this "error"

[teetwoohsix]

The one spot where it would have the Nat'l happens to have paper loss??I would think PSA would have put it on the flip.....smells funny to me.

[sreader3]

J. Doyle (N.Y. Nat'l) is only known with the Piedmont 350 back, although PSA mistakenly graded one Polar Bear example that close inspection suggests is a fake. There is an approximately zero percent chance that the card at auction is (or ever was) a legitimate J. Doyle (N.Y. Nat'l) specimen.

[Potomac Yank]

Even his Larry Fritsch story is a little on the erratic side.

[scottglevy]

My question to him:

"What gives you the confidence to claim as boldly as you do that there was a NAT'L in that space at one point which was rubbed off?

A much, much, much more likely scenario is just simple paper loss .... is there something that you know would give you a different impression?"

His response:
"I am just pointing out the area of interest on my Joe Doyle PSA card. It looks like the previous owner might have erased something. I recently purchased the PSA card off ebay and it could sell for more.
Good Luck Bidding!
Mike V."


So what's with all the hype ?! Sounds like a WAY different story than his listing. Makes for good drama though.

[BCauley]

I just read one persons question to the seller shown at the bottom of the auction. He completely failed to answer the question which would have taken all of one short sentence.

According to his past auction wins, he won it from 707 Sports