Guess the Grades!

[cliftons8]

All Authentic but trimmed.

Mike

[bobbvc]

I have an extra copy of the book and want to give it away, so here is a hint. One of these 6 cards came back as trimmed. The other 5 have numerical grades.

[Ease]

Jones 40, Lake 40, Pelty 40, Abstein 50, Criss A, Dineen 60
Thanx for the contest!

[Ease]

Originally Posted by Ease

Jones 40, Lake 40, Pelty 40, Abstein 50, Criss A, Dineen 60
Thanx for the contest!

since it's re-opened...
Jones 40, Lake 50, Pelty 30, Abstein 50, Criss A, Dineen 60

[vintagetoppsguy]

Jones - 50
Lake - 50
Pelty - 30
Abstein - 70
Criss - trimmed
Dineen - 60


Thanks!

[canjond]

Jones - Trimmed
Lake - Trimmed
Pelty - Trimmed
Abstein - 60
Criss - Trimmed
Dineen - 50

[T206Collector]

...the "trick" is that all of them were deemed trimmed by PSA, but that SGC only nailed one of them for being trimmed. The grades are really secondary.

[3-2-count]

I'll play:
Jones - 40
Lake - 50
Pelty - 40
Abstein - 60
Criss - Trimmed
Dineen - 60
If the backs have no paper loss of course....

[bobbvc]

Very clean backs- no paper loss...

[Fred]

Lake = Tr
Jones = 50
Pelty = 40
Dineen = 50
Criss = 30
Abstein = 60

[Robextend]

Jones: 40
Lake: 40
Pelty: 30
Abstein: Trim
Criss: 30
Dineen: 40

[Vol]

Jones--40
Lake--30
Pelty-A
Abstein-60
Criss--30
Dineen--50

Feel like I am off on two of them. Tough challenge!

[bobbvc]

Isaac- Not to be rude, and more as a hint to future guessers.. You got None of them right...

[chaddurbin]

building my hobby street cred...

jones-trimmed
lake-50
pelty-40
abstein-70
criss-50
dineen-50

i've intentionally left one incorrect so i wouldn't win the book

[David R]

Jones 50
Lake 40
Pelty 40
Abstein 70
Criss Trim
Dineen 60

[oldmancards]

Jones -- A
Lake -- 40
Pelty -- 30
Abstein -- 50
Criss -- 30
Dineen -- 40

Bob

[fkw]

Jones - 50
Lake - 60
Pelty - 40
Abstein - 70
Criss - Trimmed
Dineen - 60

[Bosox Blair]

Originally Posted by cliftons8

All Authentic but trimmed.

Mike

Yeah, don't know if it is Bobby's scanner that is the problem, but the only card of that whole lot that does not look trimmed to me is Pelty. Every other card looks trimmed on the top border. If that scan was for raw cards for sale, I would not touch any of them.

Cheers,
Blair

[martin neal]

Okey Dokey,

Jones 50
Lake 50
Pelty 40
Abstein 70
Criss A
Dineen 60

[nebboy]

Jones - 50
Lake - 60
Pelty - 50
Abstein - trimmed
Criss - 50
Dineen - 60

[ullmandds]

Lake A
Jones 50
Pelty 40
Abstein 50
Criss 20
Dineen 40

[Robextend]

Originally Posted by Bosox Blair

Yeah, don't know if it is Bobby's scanner that is the problem, but the only card of that whole lot that does not look trimmed to me is Pelty. Every other card looks trimmed on the top border. If that scan was for raw cards for sale, I would not touch any of them.

Cheers,
Blair

That was my original thought as well...this better not be a trick!!

[GoldenAge50s]

60-50-40
60-a-60

[tbob]

Originally Posted by Bosox Blair

Yeah, don't know if it is Bobby's scanner that is the problem, but the only card of that whole lot that does not look trimmed to me is Pelty. Every other card looks trimmed on the top border. If that scan was for raw cards for sale, I would not touch any of them.

Cheers,
Blair

I agree with Blair.
Jones - Trimmed but with large top border probably got a 60.
Lake - Trimmed (see Abstein)
Pelty - 30
Abstein - Trimmed. If this card didn't come back from SGC as authentic, I have a lot of cards like it with "bat earred" corners like this one residing in SGC AUT holders which I guess I need to resubmit
Criss - Trimmed (see Abstein)
Dineen - Trimmed (see Abstein)

[Mikehealer]

50,50,40,70,a,60

[cfc1909]

not sure what the grades are but this is what they should have been
Pelty-SGC 40 maybe 30
rest -authentic-trimmed

[AndrewJerome]

Pelty 40
Jones 50
Lake 50
Abstein 60
Criss A
Dineen 60


Andrew