1920 W519 Wilbur Robinson...Counterfeit/reprint or variation?

[FrankWakefield]

Maybe this would help a bit....

numbered
4 Ernie Kreuger
5 Babe Ruth
12 Bob Veach
13 Jesse Barnes
14 Leon Cadore

not numbered
Eddie Collins
Gabby Cravath
Frank Frisch
Rube Marquard
Guy Morton
Joe Murphy


Does that look right or possible??

[fkw]

Yes those are all right.

The W519-2-2 is a different set. it has a blue card number

Here are some examples They are very rare and I dont know of anyone that has a complete set, I dont even know who 2 of the players are (see above).




Theyve only been in the SCD for a few years now... first couple years there was only 2 cards known/checklisted (Frisch, Morton) and slowly theyve added to the checklist.

the last SCD I have is 2009 and they dont have the #11 listed, and 3 of the cards listed a "b" variations I highly doubt exist, and they would match the W519-2-1 and W521 numbers

Here is the list of known W519-2-2
#11 Kid Gleason
#12 Joe Murphy (pictured as a catcher, ?no such player?)
#13 Frank Frisch
#14 Eddie Collins
#15 UNKNOWN (might be Cravath)
#16 Guy Morton
#17 Rube Marquard
#18 UNKNOWN (might be Cravath)
#19 Ernie Kreuger
#20 Babe Ruth