Beware Carterscards2006

[docpatlv]

No...the word jackass is NOT Italian

[docpatlv]

OK...truce

[CMIZ5290]

Mike- i'll give you that one. Pretty quick response! I even tried to be politically correct and edit my response. You win that round, no offense.

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Mike- i'll give you that one. Pretty quick response! I even tried to be politically correct and edit my response. You win that round, no offense.

You have a problem with Italians?

[Rob D.]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

You have a problem with Italians?

Oh, Dan. For God's sake.

(Still climbing.)

[Rob D.]

Nice cards, Chuck!

[Sterling Sports Auctions]

No one that seems to be behind Carter has answered this question, which seems to be a strong possibility:

"For the detractors out there about Todd submitting the card to SGC. Did it dawn on you that when the seller stated that he knew GAI would sell for 20% of SGC or PSA, then why would he not try and submit his $1000 card to turn it into a $4000-$5000 card? Or maybe he did and it came back the same results as Todd got."


Lee

[bobbyw8469]

I thought I already answered that question? Speaking for myself, I wont do anymore crossovers in slabs, because I am like 0-30. I don't think the companies give their competitors a fair shake in that regard. And a high dollar card such as that one, I won't crack out either. Maybe the seller felt the same way....

[botn]

Originally Posted by bowlingshoegiverouterguy

No one that seems to be behind Carter has answered this question, which seems to be a strong possibility:

"For the detractors out there about Todd submitting the card to SGC. Did it dawn on you that when the seller stated that he knew GAI would sell for 20% of SGC or PSA, then why would he not try and submit his $1000 card to turn it into a $4000-$5000 card? Or maybe he did and it came back the same results as Todd got."


Lee

I am definitely not behind the seller, Paul Sabatino, but he certainly is within his right to sell a GAI graded card whether or not he tried to cross it. Not sure he owes any disclosure, if he did attempt a cross over. Don't think he made any assertions as to guarantee the card would cross over either so I see nothing wrong with his having sold it knowing it would sell for less. Every person who sells GAI stuff knows it will sell for less.

Greg

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by bowlingshoegiverouterguy

No one that seems to be behind Carter has answered this question, which seems to be a strong possibility:

"For the detractors out there about Todd submitting the card to SGC. Did it dawn on you that when the seller stated that he knew GAI would sell for 20% of SGC or PSA, then why would he not try and submit his $1000 card to turn it into a $4000-$5000 card? Or maybe he did and it came back the same results as Todd got."


Lee

It a STUPID question! You're asking us to speculate. Any more STUPID questions?

Edited to add: Maybe you should change your name to bowlingballgiverouterguy because the OP could definitley use some BALLS! He sits there and hides behind the eBay Buyer Protection because his card didn't cross and wants to whine. Boo Hoo! If it were any other auction or other method of purchase, he would be SOL and you, I and the OP know it.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Guys, the scan was just a suggestion. I thought if he provided a high resolution scan to show the suspected trim area, it might change my mind. Again, it was just a suggestion. The point was that he said he could prove the card was trimmed. I am asking him to do so, be it scan or some other method.

After all, Todd said that he could look at it and tell it was trimmed. Shouldn't a scan/pic help me see what he sees?