My Fred Toney Collection/Thanks to the board

[Bosox Blair]

Nice collection! And I also don't care what you do with your own cards - they are yours.

However...I have noticed a few instances lately that kind of annoy me. I'll call them "pump-and-dumps" to use a stock trading term.

Example: Day 1 - guy posts on the main Board "Hey guys show me your great rare Herpe-shiny cards...here's mine!" Attention is drawn to the cards through the thread. Day 2 - same guy posts on BST "Hey guys my Herpe-shiny is for sale to highest bidder!"

Second Example: Day 1 - guy posts on the main Board "Hey guys, I think I did well getting this card because it is worth a lot more than I paid." Friendly people post and tend to agree card has a higher value. Day 2 - same guy posts same card on BST for higher price.

Maybe these don't break any forum rules (that is for Leon to say), but I generally find these things to be transparent ploys.

Cheers,
Blair

I agree with you sir that if someone was simply trying to sell there cards at a higher price that would be bad. I considered selling the toney no trees today because my subing work has dried up a bit lately but it looks like it is picking back up so that will not be needed. While I had my card up momentarily I offered the card for less than I paid for it. I have never sold a card on the board to other members for more than I paid for it at any time.

TT

[Bosox Blair]

Originally Posted by TT40391

I agree with you sir that if someone was simply trying to sell there cards at a higher price that would be bad. I considered selling the toney no trees today because my subing work has dried up a bit lately but it looks like it is picking back up so that will not be needed. While I had my card up momentarily I offered the card for less than I paid for it. I have never sold a card on the board to other members for more than I paid for it at any time.

TT

Hi Tony,

Just to clarify my point (FWIW), I have no problem at all with people making money from selling cards. I am very much a capitalist. If I sold you a card on BST for $200 and you listed it the next day on BST for $400 I would not bat an eyelash or feel there was anything wrong with that.

The personal pet peeve I was referring to was using a post on the main Board to "set up" a BST post later. But as Leon pointed out, this could be perfectly legitimate in some cases - especially to obtain information, even if related to a future sale.

(BTW, I am happy to hear your work is picking up and I wish you the best - this economy has taken its toll on too many people!)

Cheers,
Blair

[glchen]

Yea, I think I was annoyed by that one thread that went something like, hey is that Joe Jax on this T202? Days later, guess what, I'm selling some duplicates of this card on ebay!

[Kawika]

I'm almost POSITIVE this card features Shoeless Joe...

[bh3443]

What a great collection! I really love the cabinet photo. The background is so cool with all the gentlemen in suits. Definitely a different generation.
I'm sorry to hear someone hassled you for trying to sell something. I find it out of character based on the fine group of hobbyists we have here.
Thanks again for sharing your collection. Thanks to all that posted.
You are the best,
Bill Hedin

Thanks for the kind words and support Bill.

TT

[Kawika]

Whoever wrote with the suggestion to get out of the hobby was out of line. I wonder which douchebag it was this time. I have done a couple of deals with Tony and corresponded a bit. His bona fides are as good and real as anybody else's here. Keep your head up, man.

Am I correct in surmising that Casey Stengel is sitting third from left in the Maysville cabinet?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Bosox Blair

Nice collection! And I also don't care what you do with your own cards - they are yours.

However...I have noticed a few instances lately that kind of annoy me. I'll call them "pump-and-dumps" to use a stock trading term.

Example: Day 1 - guy posts on the main Board "Hey guys show me your great rare Herpe-shiny cards...here's mine!" Attention is drawn to the cards through the thread. Day 2 - same guy posts on BST "Hey guys my Herpe-shiny is for sale to highest bidder!"

Second Example: Day 1 - guy posts on the main Board "Hey guys, I think I did well getting this card because it is worth a lot more than I paid." Friendly people post and tend to agree card has a higher value. Day 2 - same guy posts same card on BST for higher price.

Maybe these don't break any forum rules (that is for Leon to say), but I generally find these things to be transparent ploys.

Cheers,
Blair

Blair, while I agree with you, you sort of need to understand too that folks might want to find out about their items they have for sale. I am not saying anything about this particular situation (in this post), but in general. I get lots of folks asking me how to proceed with certain issues. Please be aware that I do instruct people on how to do things in order to try to conform to board protocol, while still obtaining information they are seeking. Generally, as long as they aren't selling on this main forum, then I am ok with it. It really is a judgement call and I just try to revert to common sense on stuff. Sometimes there are gray areas and I am generally going to allow folks some leeway in doing stuff, especially if:

1. they are nice enough to ask first
2. they are board regulars
3. it's obvious they are trying to do the right thing.

So, please be careful not to come down on folks too much (not saying you did) when they do something on the board. I might have told them to do it. Folks can always PM me to ask about things they see, if they have questions. This is a general statement so folks can know that sometimes things might not be exactly the way they look like. Now, that being said, there are folks that abuse the board and I try to handle those issues quickly. And lastly, please understand I am very aware of the ploys you outlined. Overall I think most members are very respectful and it's appreciated. regards

Hey David thanks for the post. I have not been able to confirm if Stengel is in this photo or not. I appreciate any feedback as to opinion's if he is in it or not. It would be great if I could confirm it or not though. Because that would make the photo a much more significant cabinet photo.

Thanks

Tony Turner

[Bosox Blair]

Originally Posted by Leon

Blair, while I agree with you, you sort of need to understand too that folks might want to find out about their items they have for sale. I am not saying anything about this particular situation (in this post), but in general. I get lots of folks asking me how to proceed with certain issues. Please be aware that I do instruct people on how to do things in order to try to conform to board protocol, while still obtaining information they are seeking. Generally, as long as they aren't selling on this main forum, then I am ok with it. It really is a judgement call and I just try to revert to common sense on stuff. Sometimes there are gray areas and I am generally going to allow folks some leeway in doing stuff, especially if:

1. they are nice enough to ask first
2. they are board regulars
3. it's obvious they are trying to do the right thing.

So, please be careful not to come down on folks too much (not saying you did) when they do something on the board. I might have told them to do it. Folks can always PM me to ask about things they see, if they have questions. This is a general statement so folks can know that sometimes things might not be exactly the way they look like. Now, that being said, there are folks that abuse the board and I try to handle those issues quickly. And lastly, please understand I am very aware of the ploys you outlined. Overall I think most members are very respectful and it's appreciated. regards

Thanks for the input, Leon!

Cheers,
Blair