This is a fake, beware

[Brian Van Horn]

This card was offered in a Glens Falls, NY auction on January 28. I don't blame the auctioneer. I advised him the card was a reprint. I did not bid.

[danmckee]

I blame the ebay auctioneer, I advised her and sent her a link to the detect fakes here. Also, that winning bidder looks fishy at 100% bidding with this seller.

[iggyman]

I'll play...

Two different auctions with obvious fake 1933 Goudey Ruth and fake 1933 Goudey Gehrig which seems to have been shilled to death...

http://www.ebay.com/itm/260947166608

Lovely Day...

[Leon]

Very fake...

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by danmckee

I blame the ebay auctioneer, I advised her and sent her a link to the detect fakes here. Also, that winning bidder looks fishy at 100% bidding with this seller.

She did add this last night:
"On Feb-07-12 at 21:43:20 PST, seller added the following information:
Since i listed this i've had 4 people tell me this is a fake or a reprint. I know nothing about baseball cards ,i've tried to research this and have found nothing about it,one person told me where to find info, i got to the site,but i couldn't get to the information about the card.. i've been looking at it and i can't tell .i'm thinking about taking it off, its late at night but i think i will cancel it in the morning."

So I think it looks like an honest mistake.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by bn2cardz

She did add this last night:
"On Feb-07-12 at 21:43:20 PST, seller added the following information:
Since i listed this i've had 4 people tell me this is a fake or a reprint. I know nothing about baseball cards ,i've tried to research this and have found nothing about it,one person told me where to find info, i got to the site,but i couldn't get to the information about the card.. i've been looking at it and i can't tell .i'm thinking about taking it off, its late at night but i think i will cancel it in the morning."

So I think it looks like an honest mistake.

It's been removed. Chalk one up for the good guys....and almost no doubt an honest mistake by the seller.