Interesting interviews regarding authenticity of the 4.4 mil Babe Ruth jersey

Bugsy · #1 05-22-2012, 09:24 PM

It would be incredibly difficult to fake a jersey like this. There are so many things to consider. I took all these into account when purchasing a pre-war jersey. I'm sure there are many things I missed too. One wrong answer to any of these can be a huge red flag.

1) Is the jersey made of the correct material? Different fabric blends and weights can be pinpointed to different time periods.

2) Who was the manufacturer?

3) Does the style of the manufacturer's tagging, wash instructions, etc. match the period the jersey was supposedly used?

4) Is the jersey the correct size for the player?

5) Does the jersey have the correct lettering font on the front?

6) Is the style of the number font correct?

7) Is the lettering the correct color?

8) Is the font placement correct?

9) Is the font material correct?

10) Does the jersey have correct buttons?

11) Does the jersey have the correct number of buttons?

12) Is the button placement correct?

13) Is the pinstriping correct?

14) Are team personalizations correct (chain-stitching, etc.)

15) Does the jersey show any alterations?

16) Does the hem match period specifications?

17) What about the taper?

18) What kind of wear does it show?

19) What about the collar style?

20) What about the armpits? There are different methods of sewing the sleeves to the shirt (and sometimes even different fabrics). Even things like the placement and number of air holes in the arm pits have to be consistent with examples from the manufacturer from that period.

Provenance and photomatching can only strengthen an argument.

The nice thing about Ruth jerseys is that several have survived. It is tougher to make a comparison when something is one of a kind.

Just food for thought.

Chris

drc · #2 05-22-2012, 11:27 PM

I note that Dave Grob is one of the top jersey experts in the field, and is as ethical and detail oriented as there is in the hobby. He's also a retired Army Lieutenant Colonel.

Fuddjcal · #3 05-23-2012, 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drc

I note that Dave Grob is one of the top jersey experts in the field, and is as ethical and detail oriented as there is in the hobby. He's also a retired Army Lieutenant Colonel.

and Chris Morales is a former secret service agent.....this means nothing.

I'm sure Dave Grob is a top expert and is ethical though. It's my experience in this hobby to EXPECT it to be FAKE first, then verify. Even if Dave says so.... "Ask Mears... it too late" does not give me much faith in the project...... and another thing.....

I have a wool suit from Nordstrom's that the moths got to after 2 years. This Jersey just "shows up" in 2004. I have a clear picture of that. it must be polyester. I'm sure it was tucked away and forgotten in grandmas ceder chest and bought at an estate sale.

travrosty · #4 05-23-2012, 11:54 AM

If only JSA did jerseys THEN I would feel 100% comfortable with this shirt.

Fuddjcal · #5 05-23-2012, 12:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by travrosty

If only JSA did jerseys THEN I would feel 100% comfortable with this shirt.

not me, I'd want to "ask Mears" and get a dual Certificate from PSA as well. Then I'd know it was real.....

seriously with all joking aside, The "ask Mears" line and "it's too late", do not come off anywhere near credible, reliable or professional when you've just sold a 4.4 million dollar item IMHO.

Splinte1941 · #6 05-23-2012, 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fuddjcal

not me, I'd want to "ask Mears" and get a dual Certificate from PSA as well. Then I'd know it was real.....

seriously with all joking aside, The "ask Mears" line and "it's too late", do not come off anywhere near credible, reliable or professional when you've just sold a 4.4 million dollar item IMHO.

Agreed. As I said previously, if the auction house peddling the item doesn't have some understanding of the authentication process they shouldn't be in the business.

drc · #7 05-23-2012, 01:06 PM

My guess is this thread involves mostly people who know little about game used jerseys. I don't know much about the area either, but I haven't offered an opinion about the jersey's authenticity.

Splinte1941 · #8 05-23-2012, 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by travrosty

If only JSA did jerseys THEN I would feel 100% comfortable with this shirt.

Love it.

Hauls of Shame has provided some unsubstantiated provenance to this jersey based on sources. Why is this so secretive?

travrosty · #9 05-23-2012, 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Splinte1941

Love it.

Hauls of Shame has provided some unsubstantiated provenance to this jersey based on sources. Why is this so secretive?

how did haulsofshame find out something about its provenance, and the auction house couldn't?

Splinte1941 · #10 05-23-2012, 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by travrosty

how did haulsofshame find out something about its provenance, and the auction house couldn't?

It's on the website...

"According to sources..."

I guess a private collector allowed the jersey to be displayed at the museum, the collector died while it was still there, and it was then sold by the family to another private collector...

Fuddjcal · #11 05-23-2012, 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bugsy

It would be incredibly difficult to fake a jersey like this. There are so many things to consider. I took all these into account when purchasing a pre-war jersey. I'm sure there are many things I missed too. One wrong answer to any of these can be a huge red flag.

1) Is the jersey made of the correct material? Different fabric blends and weights can be pinpointed to different time periods.

2) Who was the manufacturer?

3) Does the style of the manufacturer's tagging, wash instructions, etc. match the period the jersey was supposedly used?

4) Is the jersey the correct size for the player?

5) Does the jersey have the correct lettering font on the front?

6) Is the style of the number font correct?

7) Is the lettering the correct color?

8) Is the font placement correct?

9) Is the font material correct?

10) Does the jersey have correct buttons?

11) Does the jersey have the correct number of buttons?

12) Is the button placement correct?

13) Is the pinstriping correct?

14) Are team personalizations correct (chain-stitching, etc.)

15) Does the jersey show any alterations?

16) Does the hem match period specifications?

17) What about the taper?

18) What kind of wear does it show?

19) What about the collar style?

20) What about the armpits? There are different methods of sewing the sleeves to the shirt (and sometimes even different fabrics). Even things like the placement and number of air holes in the arm pits have to be consistent with examples from the manufacturer from that period.

Provenance and photomatching can only strengthen an argument.

The nice thing about Ruth jerseys is that several have survived. It is tougher to make a comparison when something is one of a kind.

Just food for thought.

Chris

How about he answered like this instead of "ask Mears". What an idiot.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
1933 Goudey #53 Babe Ruth vs 1934 "Canadian Goudey" WWG #28 Babe Ruth	Yaz#8	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	18	02-21-2012 09:31 AM
1930's Babe Ruth press photos from London, England	FourStrikes	Net54baseball Sports (Primarily) Vintage Memorabilia Forum incl. Game Used	4	05-02-2010 08:10 PM
Babe Ruth circa 1920	ErikV	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	0	03-01-2010 09:19 PM
RKO Theatres Babe Ruth Premium	GehrigFan	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	3	10-16-2009 04:26 PM
SOLD - 1921 Schapira Bros. Candy - Babe Ruth HOF (SGC Authentic)	Archive	1920 to 1949 Baseball cards- B/S/T	2	05-21-2008 02:08 PM