Success with resubmission of "trimmed" cards?

[Jetsfan]

As someone getting back into card collecting, the whole card grading thing is still relatively new to me. I had a T206 card come back as evidence of trimming from SGC. I do not believe the card is trimmed, and I know the graders are not perfect, and I suspect do not spend much time with each card they grade.

So my question is this...have any of you had success getting a card a number grade after an initial "evidence of trimming?" Have you ever had to submit more than once? Just curious, as this obviously can have significant impact upon a card's value.

Thanks...

Adam

[bnorth]

Send it to Beckett. They grade modern hand cut cards with # grades so I assume they only have a size requirement.

[ullmandds]

post a scan here...chances are we can tell u if it's trimmed or not.

[Jetsfan]

Here it is...sorry I couldn't figure out how to rotate it on my iPad.

[Eric72]

Hi Adam,

Here is your card, with the image rotated. I'm still pondering whether or not it has been trimmed...the top left corner looks a bit too "square" at first glance.

Best regards,

Eric

[ullmandds]

tough one...diamond cut looks even...top left corner def a little sharp...bottom rt edge looks wavy but I presume thats because it's a poor photo.

a scan would help.