PSA vs SGC...the definitive Debate!!!

[usernamealreadytaken]

I like SGC for consistency, customer service and value, but can't argue that PSA brings more $$. Not sure that will change . . .

[g_vezina_c55]

I prefer sgc but i also love psa cards but in my collection i have 1.5x more sgc cards.
I love the look of the SGC holder

[ullmandds]

I like SGC for consistency, customer service and value, but can't argue that PSA brings more $$. Not sure that will change . . .


+1!

[g_vezina_c55]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

I like SGC for consistency, customer service and value, but can't argue that PSA brings more $$. Not sure that will change . . .


+1!

+2 not sure too that will not change, many time when we talk about grading mistake etc, psa is almost everytime involve, so i am not sure this will not change

[GregMitch34]

Probably this has been done here already, but would be interesting for folks to make two lists (subjective):

What PSA tends to go easy on (very forgiving) in grading--and where it is very tough

Same for SGC.

[Jlighter]

Originally Posted by g_vezina_c55

+2 not sure too that will not change, many time when we talk about grading mistake etc, psa is almost everytime involve, so i am not sure this will not change

I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure PSA grades more cards which could explain more mistakes.

[SushiX37]

I agree with Zach and Jake. PSA offers a better case, easier to read grading, and tracking that can easily be accessed on their website.

Rich

[srs1a]

Definitive makes me laugh on this subject. It is a religious debate with financial overtones.

[philliesphan]

I like applesauce

[ullmandds]

John p...while i respect your opinion...you could not be more wrong!!!

[Piratedogcardshows]

I say SGC.They havent let me down yet and they have great customer service in regards to submitting cards.Jason

[Jay Wolt]

PSA has graded over 19 million cards. It would be crazy to say that they are all in the hands of investors or registry people.
I like both PSA & SGC to collect (I'm on both registries) and for re-sale, I've had very few problems with either & I'm glad both are in the hobby.

[bbcard1]

I cast my vote for GAI. And also for Mrs. Howell.

(if you are under 50 you probably don't get it).

[bbsports]

My vote goes to PRO. With PRO you know what kind of cards their grading. With SGC & PSA, it's like buying a box of Cracker Jack. You never know what your going to get.